Tribunal investigates Eastern Cape judge over alleged racist insult
High court registrar clerk Thozamile Semekazi alleges Judge Belinda Hartle used the k-word during a confrontation in May 2025.

The Judicial Conduct Tribunal is investigating allegations of gross misconduct against Eastern Cape High Court Judge Belinda Hartle. The tribunal, chaired by retired Supreme Court of Appeal Justice Boissie Mbha, began hearing evidence on Monday to determine if Hartle's behaviour amounted to gross misconduct.
Thozamile Semekazi, a court clerk with more than 20 years of experience, alleged that Hartle used racist and insulting language towards him on 15 May 2025. Semekazi claimed that after he went to the judge's secretary's office to hand over files for case management, Hartle became upset by the number of late files and began swearing at him, including using the k-word in front of secretary Shakira Frost.
Hartle has acknowledged using a swear word during the incident but maintains it was not directed at Semekazi and denies using a racist word. She accused Semekazi of grossly misrepresenting the interaction. A WhatsApp message sent by Hartle hours after the exchange apologised for using a swear word due to frustration, but stated it was not intentional or directed at him personally.
During cross-examination on Tuesday, advocate Jan Heunis SC questioned Semekazi regarding why he had not mentioned the k-word when relaying the incident to colleagues or during interactions with Hartle. Semekazi responded that he had been angry and emotional at the time. Heunis also questioned Semekazi about his medical and mental health history, including 15 applications for incapacity leave.
Semekazi told the tribunal he has suffered from major depression following the alleged incident, which has affected his work and personal life. The proceedings became emotional when questioning turned to his personal circumstances and divorce issues, prompting Semekazi to break down in tears. Justice Mbha intervened to end that line of questioning and adjourned the proceedings to allow Semekazi to compose himself.
Key facts
- The Judicial Conduct Tribunal is investigating Judge Belinda Hartle for alleged gross misconduct.
- Thozamile Semekazi alleges Judge Hartle used the k-word during a confrontation on 15 May 2025.
- Judge Hartle denies using a racist word and maintains her swear word was not directed at Semekazi.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The Judicial Conduct Tribunal is investigating allegations that Judge Belinda Hartle used racist language towards court clerk Thozamile Semekazi.
Positive
The Judicial Conduct Tribunal has commenced hearings to investigate allegations of gross misconduct.
Negative
Thozamile Semekazi stated the alleged incident left him depressed and affected his work and personal life.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
