High Court hears injunction bid by individual against media outlets

An anonymous individual known as PPT is seeking to block the publication of allegations, citing a risk of suicide, while media groups argue they have a duty to publish in the public interest.

High Court hears injunction bid by individual against media outlets
Photo: The Guardian

An anonymous individual known in court as PPT is seeking a permanent injunction to stop the publication of allegations he denies. His legal team argued that publishing the claims would likely lead to his death, noting he has made two previous attempts to take his own life.

The legal team for the media groups told the high court there are powerful countervailing considerations for publishing the claims. Lead barrister Gavin Millar KC said the outlets have not just a responsibility, but a duty to publish information believed to be in the public interest.

The investigation into PPT involved speaking to more than 100 people, including 30 who provided first-hand accounts. The media groups stated they have credible evidence of seriously improper conduct towards a large number of women over a prolonged period, including potential criminal conduct.

Many of the women making the allegations have suffered mental health crises and mental illness due to PPT's alleged conduct. The media groups believe it is important that the allegations are publicly aired to protect other women and assist the sources to recover.

PPT is seeking to block publication by citing articles of the European Convention on Human Rights relating to the right to life, inhuman or degrading treatment, and the right to respect for private and family life. The media companies argue that the European Court of Human Rights has never ruled in a way that would cause these articles to apply in this case, and they cite countervailing rights under article 10 regarding freedom of expression.

The expert noted risks could be lowered if the allegations were published while PPT was in an inpatient psychiatric setting. The trial has concluded, and Mr Justice Nicklin has retired to make a ruling.

Key facts

  • PPT is seeking a permanent injunction to stop the publication of allegations he denies.
  • The investigation included first-hand accounts from 30 people.
  • The media groups claim to have evidence of improper conduct towards many women over a prolonged period.

Three perspectives

Neutral

A high court is considering whether the right to freedom of expression outweighs the individual's claim that publication poses a risk to his life.

Positive

The media groups argue that public disclosure is necessary to protect other women and assist sources in their recovery.

Negative

The claimant's legal team argues that publishing the allegations would likely lead to his death.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition