Judge rejects DOJ attempt to file new charges against former FBI officials
A federal magistrate judge struck an unsigned and unsworn superseding complaint from the record, criticizing the Justice Department for bypassing judicial review.

A federal magistrate judge on Tuesday rejected an attempt by the Justice Department to file new criminal charges against two former FBI counterintelligence officials. Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia struck an unsigned and unsworn superseding complaint from the record that was filed after midnight on Tuesday. The complaint targeted Bradley Benavides and Nicole Floris, who are accused of lying to Congress about their role in the Hunter Biden laptop probe.
The judge noted that filing an unsworn complaint on the public docket and bypassing judicial review is unheard of.
The original criminal complaint filed last week remains intact, accusing Floris and Benavides of falsely suggesting to the House Judiciary Committee that they were unaware of government investigations involving Hunter Biden. The Justice Department later updated the docket to state that its filings were entered in error.
During the hearing, FBI agent Bryan Witt, who signed the affidavit for the new complaint, testified that the case was assigned to him in July after FBI Director Kash Patel gave the case to the Kansas City field office. Witt said the investigation initially focused on a separate matter involving Floris regarding an investigation into alleged Chinese election interference.
Defense attorneys for the former officials argued the prosecution is about a political football rather than law or facts. One attorney, Mary Dohrmann, stated that changes between the original and the attempted new complaint were substantial and raised concerns about accuracy. The legal team for Floris also accused prosecutors of trying to litigate the case in the media rather than the courtroom.
Key facts
- Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui struck an unsigned and unsworn superseding complaint from the record.
- The Justice Department is accused of bypassing judicial review by filing the complaint after midnight on Tuesday.
- Bradley Benavides and Nicole Floris face original charges of lying to the House Judiciary Committee.
Three perspectives
Neutral
A federal magistrate judge rejected a midnight filing of an unsigned superseding complaint against two former FBI officials.
Positive
The court will proceed with a preliminary hearing to determine if the original criminal complaint meets the probable cause standard.
Negative
Judge Faruqui accused the government of making bizarre moves that raise concerns and likened the actions to throwing gasoline on a fire.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.