Supreme Court hears case over religious freedom and preschool funding
Catholic preschools argue Colorado's nondiscrimination requirements for state funding violate the First Amendment.

The case, St Mary Catholic Parish v Roy, involves Catholic preschools that claim they have been shut out of a 2023 state funding program. This program provides 15 hours per week of state-funded preschool.
Colorado says the schools are welcome to participate if they agree to equal-opportunity requirements. To join, the state says schools must consent to provide eligible children an equal opportunity to enroll regardless of race, ethnicity, religious affiliation, sexual orientation, gender identity, income level, disability, or lack of housing. The plaintiffs argue that making funding contingent on that agreement amounts to unlawful religious discrimination under the First Amendment.
Nicholas Reaves, counsel at the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, said during oral arguments on Tuesday that the schools ask all enrolling families to be open to and supportive of the church's teachings. He stated that because of this sincere religious exercise, the state has denied Colorado families the ability to use universal preschool funding at Catholic schools. The archdiocese claims the state allows participating preschools to discriminate in favor of groups such as gender-nonconforming children, children of color, or members of the LGBTQ community.
The three liberal justices on the bench expressed skepticism regarding the discrimination claim. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson asked how the court should consider that some Catholic preschools were already participating in the programs. Justice Elena Kagan appeared unwilling to accept that the state implemented its neutral anti-discrimination principle with the intention of discriminating against religious schools, and Justice Sonia Sotomayor said the schools are not being excluded on their face, but are choosing not to participate because they will not get an exemption.
The US Conference of Catholic Bishops submitted an amicus brief arguing that Colorado disqualified the preschools solely because of their adherence to Catholic doctrine. The conference said the lower court's decision will embolden other states and municipalities to discriminate against religious adherents' rights by enacting ostensibly neutral statutes that discriminate in fact. It added that the resulting harm to the nation's social support infrastructure would be immense.
Key facts
- The case St Mary Catholic Parish v Roy addresses whether Colorado can require religious preschools to follow nondiscrimination rules to receive state funding.
- The 2023 state funding program provides 15 hours of preschool per week.
- A lower appeals court ruled for the state, finding that Colorado did not exclude religious preschools and had actively solicited their participation.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The case involves a clash between religious freedom and nondiscrimination laws regarding access to state-funded preschool programs.
Positive
The state of Colorado says religious preschools remain welcome to participate in the funding program.
Negative
The US Conference of Catholic Bishops argues that the state's actions could embolden other municipalities to discriminate against religious adherents' rights.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
