Observers call for US and China to respect PNG sovereignty in artillery shell case
The US and China should stop pushing narratives regarding an allegedly smuggled artillery shell and allow Papua New Guinea police to handle the investigation, an expert said.

The United States and China should stop trying to push their own narratives and allow the Papua New Guinea Police to handle the case of an allegedly smuggled artillery shell, a senior communications expert said. The shell was found in a shipping container imported by a Chinese company. PNG police detained four Chinese men in connection with the incident.
Police confirmed last week that the shell seized on Oct. 29 was a 130-millimeter round. This contradicts a claim by the Chinese embassy on social media that the object was a harmless wine bottle shaped like an artillery shell. The U.S. Embassy disputed the Chinese claim, stating the U.S. military engaged with the PNG Explosive Ordnance Disposal Unit, which determined the object was a Chinese-manufactured artillery projectile.
Joseph Ealedona, a former media executive and former president of Port Moresby Soccer Association, said the statements by the U.S. and China undermine the PNG police and the country's sovereignty. He said the matter is an active police investigation and only the PNG police will release details. Ealedona called for restraint from both embassies, stating they must respect sovereignty and refrain from making public statements.
Former diplomat Dominic Sengi wrote that the shell is part of a superpower arms race. He said PNG and the Pacific have become an increasingly important arena of strategic competition where superpowers come courting. Sengi noted that Beijing and Washington's competing explanations are instruments of political engagement.
Key facts
- Police confirmed the seized object on Oct. 29 was a 130-millimeter artillery shell.
- Four Chinese men were detained by PNG police in connection with the incident.
- The U.S. Embassy stated the PNG Explosive Ordnance Disposal Unit determined the projectile was Chinese-manufactured.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The U.S. and China have provided competing explanations regarding a 130-millimeter artillery shell seized by Papua New Guinea police.
Positive
PNG police have detained four Chinese men and are conducting an active investigation into the seized artillery shell.
Negative
Statements from the U.S. and Chinese embassies regarding the investigation undermine the jurisdiction of PNG authorities and the country's sovereignty.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.