High court reserves judgment in contempt case against correctional services officials

Carrington Laughton seeks to have correctional services head Makgothi Thobakgale and five others fined or jailed for failing to comply with a court order regarding his sentence conversion.

High court reserves judgment in contempt case against correctional services officials
Photo: Business Day

The high court in Johannesburg has reserved judgment in a contempt case brought by Carrington Laughton. Laughton, who was sentenced in 2016 to 30 years' imprisonment for the murder of restaurant chef Betty Ketani, wants correctional services head Makgothi Thobakgale and five other officials to be fined or committed to prison. The application seeks to hold the officials in contempt for failing to comply with a court order.

Acting judge Mongezi Ntanga heard the urgent application on Friday against Thobakgale, correctional services minister Pieter Groenewald, and five other officials, including Ruth Magakwe and Luckyboy Mathiba. Laughton wants Thobakgale to be ordered to comply with a July court order directing the department to consider his request to convert his direct imprisonment sentence into correctional supervision. Under correctional supervision, he would serve the remainder of his sentence at home.

Advocate Lisa Metzer, representing Laughton, argued that officials were in contempt of a July 31 order from judge Lebogang Modiba, which required them to consider the request within 30 days.

Advocate Lethabo Moepya, representing the state, argued that the department had substantially complied with the order. Moepya said Laughton was informed of the decision on September 11 and 14, which falls within 30 court days, noting that court orders should be calculated on court days excluding weekends and holidays. While conceding the state did not confirm the release date, Moepya argued this was immaterial because a decision had already been made not to recommend the conversion.

The court raised concerns that while personal cost orders were requested, no paper trail showed proof of service to all officials, although it was sent to the state attorney.

Key facts

  • The Johannesburg high court has reserved judgment on an urgent application against correctional services officials.
  • Carrington Laughton seeks to convert his 30-year murder sentence into correctional supervision.
  • The state argues it substantially complied with the court order to consider the conversion.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The Johannesburg high court has reserved judgment on whether correctional services officials are in contempt of a court order regarding Carrington Laughton's sentence conversion.

Positive

Laughton is seeking to exercise his right to have a reconsideration of his sentence conversion happen.

Negative

The state failed to comply with the specific part of the court order requiring them to confirm Laughton's release date.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Five Zimbabweans to appear in court over Russia-Ukraine war allegations
Next storyFive Zimbabweans to appear in court over Russia-Ukraine war allegations

All sections

Edition