Judge blocks DHS door-knocking practice in nine states

A federal judge ruled that Department of Homeland Security operations targeting voters likely violate the Voting Rights Act.

Judge blocks DHS door-knocking practice in nine states
Photo: CBS News

A federal judge ruled late Wednesday that the U.S. Department of Homeland Security's practice of knocking on doors and asking people about their immigration status and whether they have voted in recent elections likely violates the Voting Rights Act. U.S. District Judge Araceli Martinez-Olguin ordered federal immigration authorities to stop carrying out elections-related field operations and field interviews in nine states, including California and New York, if the operations are likely to involve people who officials know, suspect, or should reasonably know or suspect are U.S. citizens.

The order will remain in effect until polls close on Election Day. Martinez-Olguin stayed the ruling until 5 p.m. on Friday to give the government a chance to seek appeal.

The judge found the policy likely ran afoul of a section of the Voting Rights Act that makes it illegal to intimidate, threaten, or coerce those who assist people with voting or engage in voter mobilization efforts. She noted a high likelihood of error in the government's process for assembling a list of potential targets, which includes data from government agencies and commercially available data.

The Trump administration says the practice is part of an effort to crack down on voting by noncitizens, but critics say it could intimidate legal voters. Homeland Security said in a statement on Thursday that the department is laser focused on identifying, prosecuting, and removing aliens who vote and dilute the votes of U.S. citizens. The department added they have no plans to question or investigate people they believe to be U.S. citizens.

The ruling sided with groups that sued over the noncitizen voting investigation surge, including the California Nurses Association and National Nurses United. Beau Tremitiere, counsel at Protect Democracy, said the department built its lists on bad data and recklessly sent agents to homes weeks before an election.

President Trump has prioritized cracking down on voter fraud during his second term, although there has been little evidence to back up his claims of widespread voting by noncitizens. The Justice Department reported earlier this week that it arrested several dozen green card holders in California on allegations they illegally registered to vote in U.S. federal elections.

Key facts

  • Judge Araceli Martinez-Olguin ordered DHS to stop certain field operations in nine states if they likely involve U.S. citizens.
  • The ruling stays in effect until polls close on Election Day, with a stay on the ruling until 5 p.m. on Friday for appeals.
  • The Trump administration states the practice aims to crack down on noncitizen voting.

Three perspectives

Neutral

A federal judge ruled that certain Department of Homeland Security door-knocking practices likely violate the Voting Rights Act.

Positive

The ruling provides a legal check on government operations that may intimidate voters.

Negative

Critics and plaintiffs argue the DHS used bad data to send agents to people's homes, potentially intimidating legal voters.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Mary Peltola defeats Republican Dan Sullivan in Alaska Senate race
Next storyMary Peltola defeats Republican Dan Sullivan in Alaska Senate race

All sections

Edition