ICCL says Minister for Justice interfered with non-profit work

The Irish Council for Civil Liberties described Jim O’Callaghan’s comments regarding a removed Dublin Rape Crisis Centre video as unsettling.

ICCL says Minister for Justice interfered with non-profit work
Photo: The Irish Times

The Irish Council for Civil Liberties (ICCL) has said Minister for Justice Jim O’Callaghan’s comments over a controversial hugging video were unsettling. The ICCL said it is unsettling that a Minister for Justice is interfering with the work of a non-profit organisation, which is partly funded by the Department of Justice, and pressuring it to pull and delete a video that seeks to educate people about consent.

The Dublin Rape Crisis Centre (DRCC) has removed a consent video featuring grandparents hugging their grandchildren following widespread public criticism. In the video, which was meant to highlight consent, a girl was visibly uncomfortable receiving a hug from her grandparents. A voiceover in the video said, “Not everyone wants a hug. Even from the people who love them. Absolutely.”

Jim O’Callaghan issued a statement after the video generated controversy online, saying the video does not represent the views of the Government. He said the video was both inappropriate and demeaning to grandparents and was removed by the DRCC following engagement with his officials. O’Callaghan said that while ensuring people understand consent in sexual relationships is vital, the video did not advance that aim and was counterproductive in many ways.

The ICCL cited a report from two years ago which found that State funding can create pressure on civil society organisations to limit their advocacy and campaigning. The organisation said such episodes risk creating a pervasive chilling effect and self-censorship within civil society. The ICCL also stated these incidents raise serious questions about Government or ministerial interference in the work of civil society.

Key facts

  • The Dublin Rape Crisis Centre removed a consent video after public criticism and engagement with officials from the Minister for Justice.
  • Jim O’Callaghan said the video was inappropriate, demeaning to grandparents, and did not represent Government views.
  • The Irish Council for Civil Liberties said the Minister's actions risk creating a chilling effect and self-censorship in civil society.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The Dublin Rape Crisis Centre removed a consent video after it drew public criticism and engagement from the Minister for Justice's officials.

Positive

The ICCL noted that the removal of the video will likely lead to valuable conversations about the understanding of consent among friends and families.

Negative

The ICCL said the Minister's comments and pressure on the non-profit organisation were unsettling and risk creating a chilling effect on civil society.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Crude but viable device made safe in Dublin's Merrion Square
Next storyCrude but viable device made safe in Dublin's Merrion Square

All sections

Edition