Police close Andrew Frederick case despite homicide ruling

Charity workers and the family of Andrew Frederick are demanding government intervention after Grenadian police closed a case involving a death ruled a homicide by a pathologist.

Police close Andrew Frederick case despite homicide ruling
Photo: The Guardian

Grenadian police have closed the case of Andrew Frederick, despite an autopsy report ruling his death a homicide. The pathologist stated that Frederick, 47, suffered blunt force trauma and was tortured, including by the removal of a toenail.

The family of Frederick, whose body was found on 4 January, says they are still waiting for Grenada to approve a formal request to cooperate with a UK investigation. A British high commissioner raised the case with officials at the highest levels of government in Grenada, and authorities there had agreed to cooperate with any forthcoming formal request.

After a campaign by the family, Frederick's body was repatriated to the UK in August, where a second autopsy discovered his brain, heart, lungs, and other organs were missing. The family described the discovery that parts of his neck and all his organs were missing as shocking and devastating.

David Johnston, a former Scotland Yard homicide commander supporting the family, said the police failed to properly identify and preserve the crime scene. He stated that in homicide investigations, the first 24 hours are the most important because evidence can be lost if a crime scene is not properly managed.

Eve Henderson, founder of the Murdered Abroad charity, called on the foreign affairs select committee to step in. She said the family is being met with obfuscation almost 10 months after the death.

An FCDO spokesperson said they are supporting the family of the British man who died in Grenada and are in contact with local authorities.

Key facts

  • Andrew Frederick's death was ruled a homicide by a pathologist who found evidence of blunt force trauma and torture.
  • A second autopsy in the UK discovered that Frederick's organs and parts of his neck were missing.
  • A formal request from the UK for Grenada to cooperate with the investigation remains unsigned.

Three perspectives

Neutral

Grenadian police closed the case of Andrew Frederick after finding no basis that a homicide occurred, despite an autopsy ruling the death a homicide.

Positive

British authorities have raised the case with high-level officials in Grenada, and authorities there indicated they would cooperate with formal requests for assistance.

Negative

The family of Andrew Frederick says they are still waiting for Grenada to honour a verbal commitment to cooperate with the UK investigation.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition