Justice Kagan criticises conservative Supreme Court majority

Justice Elena Kagan said the country was in a better place when the Supreme Court was more ideologically balanced.

Justice Kagan criticises conservative Supreme Court majority
Photo: Bloomberg Law News

Justice Elena Kagan said the country was in a better place when the Supreme Court was more balanced, expressing frustration with her colleagues on a deeply conservative court. During an appearance at Catholic University’s law school on Oct. 20, Kagan argued the conservative majority blinded itself to the damaging effects of its rulings for US democracy.

Kagan, who was appointed by President Barack Obama in 2010, identified the year after Justice Antonin Scalia’s death in 2016 as the epitome of balance because a 4-4 split forced justices to compromise and listen to each other. She stated that when the court had legitimacy, it helped to create a stable country.

Other justices have also shared misgivings about life within the court. Justice Clarence Thomas said in an August podcast that the court has changed a bit since the 2022 leak of a draft opinion regarding abortion rights, noting that there was once trust and honor even during disagreement.

Security concerns have also been raised by members of the court. Justice Amy Coney Barrett shared experiences of facing threats following the Dobbs ruling and a May incident involving an attempted swatting at her home. Kagan testified in July that four-to-eight-member protection details now accompany justices almost everywhere.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor said in September that she has lost some positive feelings toward the model of nine justices hearing every case because she is dissenting too much. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson also spoke in July about not being able to live a normal life.

Key facts

  • Justice Elena Kagan said the country was in a better place when the Supreme Court was more balanced.
  • Kagan testified in July that protection details of four to eight members accompany justices almost everywhere.

Three perspectives

Neutral

Justices have used public appearances to voice misgivings about their work and life within an ideologically fractured court.

Positive

Justice Neil Gorsuch noted that justices often reach unanimous decisions and said they have a good time together when disagreeing.

Negative

Kagan argued the conservative majority blinded itself to the damaging effects of its rulings for US democracy.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition