Semantan Estate Sues Govt
Seeks sale of RM13b Duta Enclave land or compensation, company claims government holds land in trust
Semantan Estate (1952) Sdn Bhd and its liquidator have filed a new lawsuit against the government, seeking a court order to compel the sale of the Duta Enclave land in Kuala Lumpur. The company estimates the land's current market value at RM12 billion to RM13 billion.
The suit, filed at the Kuala Lumpur High Court, names six defendants, including the Malaysian government, the Federal Land Commissioner, and the Natural Resources and Environmental Sustainability minister.
Semantan Estate is seeking a declaration that the government holds the land in trust for the company, as well as a court order directing the government to sell the land within a specified period.
Alternatively, the company is seeking equitable compensation for the alleged breach of trust or damages under Article 13 of the Federal Constitution for the alleged deprivation of its property rights.
The case has been fixed for case management before High Court Judge Datuk Anand Ponnudurai on November 3.
This is the third legal action brought by Semantan Estate against the government over the disputed land.
The company has two separate ongoing suits before the High Court, which remain pending, including one for adequate compensation to be calculated and given to the company according to the December 1956 rate.
Key facts
- Semantan Estate estimates the Duta Enclave land's current market value at RM12 billion to RM13 billion.
- The company is seeking a court order to compel the government to sell the land.
- The government is named as one of the six defendants in the lawsuit.
- The case is set for case management on November 3.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The lawsuit is the latest development in a long-standing dispute between Semantan Estate and the government over the Duta Enclave land. The company's claim that the government holds the land in trust will be tested in court. The outcome of the case will depend on the court's interpretation of the law and the evidence presented.
Positive
Semantan Estate's lawsuit may lead to a resolution of the dispute and provide clarity on the company's rights to the land. If successful, the company may receive significant compensation for the land's value.
Negative
The lawsuit may be seen as an attempt by Semantan Estate to pressure the government into selling the land or providing compensation. The company's claim that the government holds the land in trust may be disputed, and the court may rule in favor of the government.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.