UK watchdog warns of extraordinary risk to taxpayers over Sizewell C costs

The public accounts committee says bill payers could face an extra £9.8bn in construction costs and £12bn in operating costs for the nuclear plant.

UK watchdog warns of extraordinary risk to taxpayers over Sizewell C costs
Photo: The Guardian

The UK public accounts committee (PAC) has warned that the cost of the Sizewell C nuclear reactor could spiral to almost £48bn. This would leave bill payers responsible for an extra £9.8bn to construct the plant before 2040 and a further £12bn over its 60-year operating life.

The government expects the project to cost between £40.5bn and £47.7bn, with construction completed between 2039 and 2043. Taxpayers and consumers face a high level of risk after the government agreed to take a near-45% stake in the plant.

The government was forced to take a larger share of the project after buying out Chinese state nuclear developer CGN, which had been allowed to hold a 20% stake before national security concerns emerged. Private investors, including Centrica which holds a 15% share, the Canadian investment group La Caisse with 20%, and Amber Infrastructure with a 7.6% stake, would only need to provide an extra £30m if costs overrun.

PAC chair Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown said the high level of risk borne by taxpayers and consumers is extraordinary. He said private investors look set for significant returns while customers are likely to be saddled with higher energy bills. He urged the government to focus on the successful delivery of the project to build confidence in the UK nuclear industry.

A government spokesperson said the report ignores that investors are incentivised to complete construction as cheaply and quickly as possible through the terms of the deal. The spokesperson added that once operational, Sizewell C could save £2bn a year across the energy system and that the project is making progress with over 2,000 workers on site.

The committee has called on the government to provide the scenario analysis used to underpin its cost estimates within the next three months. It also asked ministers to provide an update on the project's development every six months.

Key facts

  • Sizewell C costs could reach almost £48bn.
  • Bill payers could face £9.8bn in construction costs and £12bn in operating costs.
  • The government expects construction to be completed between 2039 and 2043.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The government expects Sizewell C to cost between £40.5bn and £47.7bn with construction finishing by 2043.

Positive

A government spokesperson said the project could save £2bn a year across the energy system once operational.

Negative

The public accounts committee warned that taxpayers and consumers face an extraordinary level of risk and could be saddled with higher energy bills.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Next storyGovernment targets ghost workers and wage bill through reforms

All sections

Edition