Overhang phenomenon gives parties outright control of seven councils

An electoral quirk resulted in seven councils gaining outright majorities without a majority of the vote, with the ANC benefiting most from the 71 overhang seats identified.

Overhang phenomenon gives parties outright control of seven councils
Photo: News24

Overhang occurs when a party wins more ward seats than its overall share of the vote would entitle it to under proportional representation. In these cases, the party won every single ward in the municipality.

In 33 councils, the overhang swelled one party's seat count beyond what voters awarded it at the expense of other parties. Of the 71 overhang seats identified across the country, 93% went to the ANC. The ANC stands to benefit in four of these councils, while the MK Party stands to benefit in two cases.

Rise Tsantsabane Communities gained control of the Northern Cape municipality the party is named after. In the four metros of Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni, Nelson Mandela Bay and Mangaung, overhangs occurred but did not manufacture a majority. The ANC will receive eight overhang seats in Johannesburg and nine in Ekurhuleni, plus one seat each in Nelson Mandela Bay and Mangaung.

South Africa's local government electoral system splits council seats evenly between directly elected ward councillors and proportional representation (PR) seats. PR seats are intended to top up each party's ward wins so that its total seats reflect its share of the vote. However, when a party wins more wards than its vote share justifies, those ward seats cannot be taken away.

The impact of these seats can be significant, particularly in smaller municipalities where one or two extra seats make a larger difference than in larger councils. In the metros, the absence of PR lists means outgoing mayors and other senior party members in those regions will not return to council.

Key facts

  • The ANC received 93% of the 71 overhang seats identified across the country.
  • Overhang gave parties outright control of seven councils without a majority of the vote.
  • In 33 councils, the overhang swelled one party's seat count beyond its proportional entitlement.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The overhang phenomenon resulted in 71 seats across 33 councils being allocated beyond proportional representation entitlements.

Positive

Rise Tsantsabane Communities gained control of the Northern Cape municipality the party is named after.

Negative

The overhang swelled one party's seat count beyond what voters awarded it at the expense of the other parties.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Next storyGovernment targets ghost workers and wage bill through reforms

All sections

Edition