Fed minutes show hawkish debate over potential larger rate hikes
Minutes from the October 27-28 meeting reveal a substantial bloc of policymakers favored a 50 basis point hike, despite the decision to hold rates.

Minutes from the October 27-28 FOMC meeting indicate that the 10-2 vote to hold rates understated the hawkish tone of the meeting. A substantial bloc of participants leaned toward a hike in October, and some officials would have accepted a hold only because market pricing already anticipated more increases.
Several participants suggested a larger move of more than 25 basis points could be considered if inflation data proved unfavorable. Waller had previously set a 0.3% core threshold for a 50 basis point hike, a level the October CPI report met.
The decision to hold was conditional, as policymakers noted that market pricing for December was performing part of the work and made it safe to wait. While some officials argued for a gradual 25 basis point approach in December to allow households and businesses to adjust, this was a minority view.
The dovish perspective relies on current financial conditions, including rising mortgage rates, widening junk spreads, falling bank shares, and increased scrutiny of AI financing. Currently, the market has 62 basis points of hikes priced in over the next three meetings.
Inflation remaining above the 2% target is driving central bank officials toward a more aggressive stance.
Key facts
- The October 27-28 FOMC meeting minutes show a substantial group of policymakers favored a hike.
- Some participants suggested a move larger than 25 basis points if inflation data was unfavorable.
- The October CPI met the 0.3% core threshold Waller set for a 50 basis point hike.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The FOMC minutes from the October 27-28 meeting show a debate between officials favoring aggressive hikes and those advocating for a gradual approach.
Positive
Some officials argued for a gradual approach to allow households and businesses time to adjust to changes.
Negative
Inflation remains above the 2% target, pushing officials toward a more aggressive stance.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
