Court rejects mushroom murderer's appeal and rules she may never be released

An appeals court found Erin Patterson's crimes were extraordinarily cold and calculated, ruling her previous 33-year non-parole period was inadequate.

An appeals court has rejected an attempt by Erin Patterson to overturn her murder convictions, ruling that her original sentence was too light for her crimes. Three judges in Victoria's Court of Appeal on Friday threw out her appeal and agreed with the prosecution that her sentence was inadequate because it allowed for the possibility of freedom.

Patterson, 52, was found guilty of murdering three relatives and attempting to kill another by serving a toxic mushroom-laced beef Wellington meal in 2023. The victims were her in-laws, Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson. She was also convicted of the attempted murder of Heather's husband, Ian Wilkinson, a local pastor who survived the meal but has ongoing health issues.

Justice Stephen McLeish, speaking for the panel, said the crimes were extraordinarily cold and calculated and must be denounced in the strongest terms. The court concluded the case involved such shocking criminality that it is inappropriate to fix a non-parole period, meaning Patterson may never be released from prison.

The offending involved an elaborate series of deceptions, including claims that she had cancer and lying about the source of the mushrooms. Justice McLeish stated that Patterson sustained an intent to murder all four people for three weeks, spanning from the time they were invited to the lunch through their protracted suffering and deaths.

Patterson was previously sentenced to life imprisonment with a 33-year non-parole period, a term the trial judge set due to the harsh prison conditions she would likely face. Her legal team had argued that a hotel booking mishap and the use of certain evidence, such as cell tower data and Facebook posts, undermined the integrity of her trial.

Patterson has 28 days to decide if she will seek to convince the High Court of Australia to hear another appeal.

Key facts

  • Erin Patterson was convicted of murdering Don and Gail Patterson and Heather Wilkinson, and attempting to murder Ian Wilkinson.
  • The Victoria Court of Appeal ruled that Patterson's crimes were so shocking that no non-parole period should be fixed.
  • Patterson's legal team argued that a hotel booking mishap and certain pieces of evidence were prejudicial to her trial.

Three perspectives

Neutral

Erin Patterson's appeal against her murder convictions was rejected by Victoria's Court of Appeal on Friday.

Positive

The court ruled that the sentence should be increased to ensure the shocking criminality is denounced.

Negative

The court found that Patterson's crimes were extraordinarily cold and calculated, involving an elaborate series of deceptions.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Next storyThe Gambia brings genocide case against Myanmar to international court

All sections

Edition