Individual seeks injunction to block news allegations citing suicide risk

A claimant referred to as PPT is seeking a permanent injunction against the Guardian and ITN, arguing that publishing allegations would likely lead to his death.

Individual seeks injunction to block news allegations citing suicide risk
Photo: The Guardian

An individual referred to in court as PPT is seeking a permanent injunction against the Guardian and ITN to stop them from publishing allegations which he denies. His legal team argued at the opening of a two-day trial that publishing the allegations would be a highly exceptional case and would highly likely lead him to commit suicide.

The claimant's legal team said PPT suffers from very severe mental health problems. Lead barrister Sara Mansoori KC stated that PPT first attempted to commit suicide in May when the Guardian and ITN contacted him to respond to the allegations, leading to his admission to hospital as a voluntary patient. The court was told PPT made a second attempt to take his life in July by absconding from a secure hospital.

PPT is seeking to block the publication by citing article two of the European Convention on Human Rights relating to the right to life, article three relating to inhuman or degrading treatment, and article eight which protects the right to respect for private and family life. Mansoori pointed to medical evidence that PPT's life would be endangered if the allegations were published.

The news outlets said the allegations involved more than 30 sources with first-hand accounts as part of a wide-ranging and rigorous investigation. They will argue that the European Court of Human Rights has never required a state to prevent the publication of journalism to protect against an individual's risk of suicide. They also stated that any duties towards PPT should come through NHS mental health treatment and powers under the Mental Health Act.

An independent expert assessment stated that community arrangements would not be sufficient to manage the immediate suicide risk regarding the prospect of publishing the allegations. The expert concluded that publication while the claimant remains in an inpatient psychiatric setting would be significantly safer in terms of reducing the likelihood of a successful suicide.

Mr Justice Nicklin opened the trial with a warning about online speculation that has named several different individuals. He asked that the court be allowed to perform its task without further attempts to identify PPT or any other protected person.

Key facts

  • PPT is seeking a permanent injunction against the Guardian and ITN to block allegations he denies.
  • The claimant's legal team argues that publishing the allegations would highly likely lead to his suicide.
  • The news outlets state the allegations involve more than 30 sources with first-hand accounts.

Three perspectives

Neutral

A London court is hearing a case regarding whether the right to freedom of journalism outweighs an individual's claim that publication poses a fatal risk to their mental health.

Positive

The news outlets have conducted a wide-ranging and rigorous investigation involving more than 30 sources with first-hand accounts.

Negative

The claimant's legal team stated that publishing the allegations would highly likely lead him to commit suicide.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition