Elim Hotel licence suspended for six weeks over whale diving video
The establishment's fleet was limited to one boat after guests posted footage of prohibited diving with humpback whales.

Tonga has suspended the licence of Elim Hotel for six weeks after guests posted a video of diving with humpback whales. The establishment's fleet was also limited to one boat. While swimming alongside whales is allowed, diving with them is prohibited in the country.
Elim Hotel manager Lepolo Foliaki said the rules were breached by guests. According to her, the person responsible for advertising must ensure it clearly states that going underwater near whales is prohibited. Footage from Chinese social media shows tourists touching the animals and diving with them.
Lemoto Fakaosi, director of the Ministry of Tourism division in Vava'u, said several operators had received warnings for violating the rules. Local tourism business owner Vili Vaipulu said such advertising misleads clients and makes the work of captains trying to comply with the diving ban more difficult. He also claims to have seen cases of vessel overloading and operators working on Sundays, when Tonga's constitution prohibits commercial activity.
About 2,000 humpback whales arrive in Tonga's waters annually, travelling from Antarctica to give birth in the Vava'u islands. Swimming with whales attracts around 20,000 tourists to the kingdom each year and generates about $12 million in revenue. A 2019 study by Lorenzo Fiori of Auckland University of Technology found low compliance with Tongan rules.
Karen Stone, environmental director of the Vava'u Environmental Protection Association, warned that such activity could disrupt whales' natural behaviour, which is important for the sustainability of the population. A group of local operators is also challenging the government's licensing decision in court. One member of the group, Alistair Coldrick, believes the government is not following its own rules and that increasing the number of permits is placing additional pressure on whales.
Key facts
- Elim Hotel's licence was suspended for six weeks following a video of guests diving with humpback whales.
- Diving with whales is prohibited in Tonga, though swimming alongside them is permitted.
- The whale-watching industry generates approximately $12 million in annual revenue for the kingdom.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The government suspended Elim Hotel's licence for six weeks after guests posted a video of prohibited whale diving.
Positive
The suspension of the licence and the limitation of the hotel's fleet represent an enforcement of national rules.
Negative
Advertising for freediving tours may mislead clients and makes it harder for captains to comply with the diving ban.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.