Prediction markets face test as trading volume hits $21bn

Polymarket and Kalshi face scrutiny following high-profile election forecasting errors as trading volume reaches a monthly record of $21bn.

Prediction markets face test as trading volume hits $21bn
Photo: The Guardian

Trading volume for prediction markets Polymarket and Kalshi reached a monthly record of $21bn this October. This follows a period before the 2024 presidential election when volume surpassed $90m, compared to just over $4m in October 2022.

The platforms are facing a test of their authority during the US midterms. Proponents argue that prices on these markets are more accurate than polls and faster than newsrooms. Polymarket founder and chief executive Shayne Coplan said last year that Polymarket is the most accurate thing mankind has right now until a super crystal ball is created.

However, the markets have been confidently wrong across several high-profile elections. In Brazil, Polymarket priced a victory for Flávio Bolsonaro at about 80% on election day, but Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva won with 51.8% of the vote. In Serbia, Polymarket gave Aleksandar Vučić’s United Serbia a 70% chance of winning, but the opposition Student List took 52.6% of the vote.

In August, Polymarket and Kalshi gave Francesca Hong roughly a 95% chance in the Wisconsin Democratic governor’s primary. Her rival, David Crowley, won by less than half a percentage point, and Hong finished third.

The industry has moved from the fringes of finance into public life. Newsrooms have signed deals to integrate live election odds into their coverage. The CFTC states on its website that event contracts can sometimes forecast outcomes better than polling and help the public forecast, plan for, hedge, and harness perceptions of future outcomes.

Key facts

  • Trading volume for Polymarket and Kalshi reached $21bn this October.
  • Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva won the Brazilian election with 51.8% of the vote despite prediction markets pricing a Bolsonaro victory at 80%.
  • In the Wisconsin Democratic governor’s primary, Francesca Hong finished third despite markets giving her a 95% chance of winning.

Three perspectives

Neutral

Prediction markets aggregate the independent judgments of many traders to provide continuously updating estimates of outcome probabilities.

Positive

The CFTC states that event contracts can help the public forecast, plan for, hedge, and harness perceptions of future outcomes.

Negative

The markets have been confidently wrong across a string of high-profile elections.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition