Federal Constitutional Court dismisses review petitions on Income Support Levy ruling
The court dismissed dozens of petitions seeking a review of a 2021 Supreme Court ruling and questioned a 2022 decision to hear similar constitutional questions.

The Federal Constitutional Court in Islamabad has dismissed dozens of petitions seeking a review of the Supreme Court’s December 28, 2021, ruling on the Income Support Levy Act 2013.
A bench comprising Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan and Justice Ali Baqar Najafi considered the petitions concerning the 2021 ruling. The court found no apparent error or other fundamental defect in the 2021 ruling that could justify its review.
The court expressed serious concerns over the actions of a Supreme Court bench that in 2022 agreed to hear largely identical constitutional questions, even though the earlier ruling remained in force and had already been subject to review.
In 2021, a Supreme Court bench comprising Aminuddin Khan and Qazi Faez Isa concluded that the Income Support Levy Act 2013 had not acquired the status of an effective law. The court ruled the act was enacted through the Finance Act 2013 without following the legislative procedure stipulated by the Constitution.
The main question was whether the levy introduced through the Finance Act 2013 could be enacted under the constitutional category of a Money Bill pursuant to Article 73(2) of Pakistan’s Constitution. The court concluded that despite its financial implications, the levy did not fall within that category and should have undergone the ordinary legislative procedure involving both houses of parliament.
The Chief Justice of the Federal Constitutional Court noted that subsequent or co-equal judicial benches must properly take previous court rulings into account. Departing from them must comply with the rules of judicial precedent and established institutional procedure.
Key facts
- The Federal Constitutional Court dismissed dozens of petitions seeking a review of the December 28, 2021, Supreme Court ruling on the Income Support Levy Act 2013.
- The court found the Income Support Levy Act 2013 was enacted through the Finance Act 2013 without following the constitutional legislative procedure.
- The court ruled the levy did not fall under the category of a Money Bill pursuant to Article 73(2) of the Constitution.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The Federal Constitutional Court dismissed petitions to review the 2021 Income Support Levy Act ruling and questioned a 2022 Supreme Court decision to hear similar issues.
Positive
The court upheld the principle that subsequent or co-equal judicial benches must properly take previous court rulings into account.
Negative
The court expressed serious concerns regarding a 2022 Supreme Court bench that agreed to hear constitutional questions identical to a previous ruling.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.