Supreme Court to weigh limits of third-country deportation policy
The high court will decide a challenge to the Trump administration's practice of removing migrants to countries other than their own in December.

The Supreme Court will weigh the legal limits of the Trump administration's third-country deportation policy in December. The case, Department of Homeland Security v. D.V.D., concerns people with final removal orders who face deportation to countries that were neither designated in their removal orders nor previously identified in writing as potential destinations.
The policy allows the government to remove some migrants to countries other than their own. Under guidance issued in March 2025, Department of Homeland Security officials first determine if a receiving country has provided assurances that people will not be persecuted or tortured. If the State Department considers those assurances credible, the agency permits removal without further procedures.
The practice has faced legal challenges, including a class-action lawsuit. In September, the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals largely upheld a lower-court judgment against the Department of Homeland Security. The appeals court concluded that statutes and regulations require effective notice and a meaningful opportunity to raise fear-based claims before removal to a third country.
The Department of Homeland Security has disputed the lower courts' interpretation. The agency argues that immigration law gives the executive branch discretion over third-country removals and does not establish the additional procedures imposed by lower courts. The government also argues that court-imposed restrictions create operational burdens and threaten diplomatic arrangements.
The high court has allowed the policy to remain in effect while the litigation proceeds, but it has not ruled that the policy itself is lawful. The Supreme Court first intervened in the case on June 23, 2025, when it stayed a preliminary injunction issued by U.S. District Judge Brian Murphy.
Key facts
- The Supreme Court will decide the legal limits of the third-country deportation policy in December.
- The Department of Homeland Security argues that immigration law gives the executive branch discretion over these removals.
- The 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that migrants must receive notice and a meaningful opportunity to contest removal to a third country.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The Supreme Court is preparing to decide a major challenge to the Trump administration's use of third-country deportations in December.
Positive
The Supreme Court has allowed the policy to remain in effect while the litigation proceeds.
Negative
The policy involves removing migrants to countries that were not designated in their removal orders or previously identified as destinations.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.