Judge dismisses Mariah Carey's brother's defamation lawsuit

Judge Leslie Stroth threw out Morgan Carey's complaint, finding he failed to prove his sister acted with actual malice in her memoir.

Judge dismisses Mariah Carey's brother's defamation lawsuit
Photo: The Guardian

Judge Leslie Stroth dismissed a defamation complaint filed by Morgan Carey against his sister, singer Mariah Carey, in documents filed on Monday. The judge found that Morgan Carey failed to show his sister knew what she was writing was false or that she recklessly disregarded the truth. Morgan Carey's belief that his sister felt ill will towards him was insufficient proof of actual malice, the judge wrote.

Morgan Carey originally sued in New York's supreme court in 2021, alleging that Mariah Carey's memoir, The Meaning of Mariah Carey, falsely portrayed him as a violent drug dealer with a criminal record. He claimed the memoir ruined him and caused extreme mental anguish. He also alleged the production of a film he co-wrote was cancelled because a producer feared angering his sister, and he sought in excess of $1.5m for the cancellation.

A previous ruling by Jaffe had found that Carey could be liable for defamation regarding claims that Morgan Carey sold cocaine in the 1980s and had been in the system. Jaffe also found that claims regarding physical abuse and accepting money to murder someone could be defamatory, but noted Morgan Carey failed to demonstrate he had suffered damages.

Mariah Carey's lawyer, John Rosenberg, said she is gratified that the court recognised her memoir addresses significant issues of public interest and dismissed the claims in their entirety. He stated Carey believes the decision confirms that authors must be afforded broad protection when speaking on matters of public concern.

Richard Roth, one of Morgan Carey's attorneys, said on Tuesday that he would appeal again.

Key facts

  • Judge Leslie Stroth dismissed Morgan Carey's defamation complaint against Mariah Carey.
  • Morgan Carey sought in excess of $1.5m related to a film's cancellation.
  • Richard Roth, an attorney for Morgan Carey, stated he would appeal the ruling.

Three perspectives

Neutral

Judge Leslie Stroth dismissed Morgan Carey's defamation lawsuit against Mariah Carey, finding he failed to prove actual malice.

Positive

Mariah Carey's lawyer said she is gratified that the court recognised her memoir addresses significant issues of public interest.

Negative

Morgan Carey alleged the memoir ruined him, caused extreme mental anguish, and led to the cancellation of a film he co-wrote.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition