Florida judge denies BBC motion to dismiss Trump defamation claim
A judge ruled that Donald Trump has plausibly alleged actual malice regarding the editing of a Panorama documentary.

A Florida district court judge has partially denied a motion by the BBC to dismiss a $10bn (£7.5bn) defamation lawsuit brought by Donald Trump. District Judge Jeffrey Kuntz ruled that the president plausibly alleged he suffered reputational harm due to the editing of a Panorama documentary titled Trump: A Second Chance.
The lawsuit stems from the splicing of disparate comments made by Trump before the 6 January US Capitol insurrection. The judge noted that the editing combined comments made nearly 55 minutes apart, a decision the BBC has apologised for.
The judge also noted that past errors in the broadcaster's coverage could be probative of the BBC's state of mind regarding recklessness. However, the court dismissed Trump's claim that the BBC violated Florida's Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act. Trump must still prove he suffered actual damages from the documentary, which was not broadcast in Florida.
The BBC said it was surprised by the decision but respects the court's authority and will respond through the proper legal process. Trump called the ruling a "huge victory" on Truth Social.
The allegations regarding the documentary led the then-BBC director-general Tim Davie to announce his resignation. BBC chairman Samir Shah apologised for an "error of judgment" and accepted the editing gave the impression of a direct call for violent action.
A Florida magistrate judge previously ruled that Trump must sit for a deposition by lawyers for the BBC by 11 December or face sanctions. The BBC has been ordered to file a response to the ruling by 1 December.
Key facts
- Judge Jeffrey Kuntz declined to dismiss Donald Trump's $10bn defamation claim against the BBC.
- The claim involves the editing of a Panorama documentary about the US Capitol riots.
- The judge found Trump plausibly alleged actual malice due to the time disparity between edited statements.
Three perspectives
Neutral
A Florida judge ruled that Donald Trump's defamation claim against the BBC can proceed to the next stage, though he must prove actual malice and damages at trial.
Positive
Donald Trump described the ruling as a "huge victory" against the broadcaster.
Negative
The BBC warned that the lawsuit could have a chilling effect on reporting about public figures.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.