Iowa teacher wins $425,000 over racial harassment claims
A jury awarded Robert Bender compensatory damages after finding his school district and two administrators failed to address repeated racial slurs used by students.

A jury awarded Robert Bender $425,000 in compensatory damages after determining that the Ottumwa Community School District and two senior administrators failed to address repeated racial harassment by students. Bender, a Black special education teacher at Evans Middle School in Ottumwa, Iowa, alleged that students repeatedly called him the N-word during the 2021-22 academic year.
Bender accused the school district, principal Jerry Miller, and assistant principal Dana Warnecke of failing to take sufficient disciplinary action. He testified that the harassment occurred nearly every week while he taught students with behavioral disabilities. The lawsuit claimed the lack of discipline emboldened students to continue the behavior in front of staff and administration.
The defendants argued that working with middle school students with behavioral disabilities required a different style of discipline. They stated their approach prioritized positive behavioral support rather than automatic suspensions, citing the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. Miller explained at a deposition that for students with behavioral disabilities, each day is a fresh start.
Bender argued that disciplinary decisions were inconsistent, noting that some students received less severe consequences than others for misconduct. He submitted records showing one student was suspended for fighting and defiance, but the student's records did not list the racial slurs despite Bender's reports.
The jury reached its decision after approximately five and a half hours of deliberation following four days of testimony. While the jury also awarded $100 in punitive damages to each administrator, U.S. District Judge Stephen H. Locher later threw out those specific awards because evidence did not show Miller and Warnecke acted with malice or reckless indifference.
Key facts
- Robert Bender won $425,000 in compensatory damages.
- The lawsuit targeted the Ottumwa Community School District, principal Jerry Miller, and assistant principal Dana Warnecke.
- The jury awarded $100 in punitive damages to each administrator, but the judge later threw out those awards.
Three perspectives
Neutral
A jury awarded Robert Bender $425,000 after finding the Ottumwa Community School District and two administrators failed to address repeated racial harassment by students.
Positive
The jury awarded Robert Bender $425,000 in compensatory damages.
Negative
Bender alleged that the school's lack of discipline emboldened students to continue using racial slurs.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.