Authorities pause AV testing in Punggol after near-miss and U-turn incidents
Grab and ComfortDelGro autonomous vehicle trials face pauses following a near-miss with a schoolgirl and a vehicle turning into the path of another at a Punggol junction.
Authorities have directed Grab to pause testing at certain junctions and told ComfortDelGro to pause U-turns at the Punggol Field junction as a precaution. These directions follow two incidents involving autonomous vehicles (AVs) testing new routes for enhanced on-demand services. In one incident, a Grab AV appeared to come close to hitting a schoolgirl making a discretionary left turn at a traffic junction. A separate dashcam video showed a ComfortDelGro AV turning into the path of an approaching vehicle while attempting a U-turn at a junction in Punggol Field on Nov 5.
The incidents have caused concern among Punggol residents, particularly parents of young children. Mr Tan Kar Yeow, 46, said he is worried and sceptical about boarding the vehicles with his family. Ms Nurul Farhah Zulkiflee, 28, said she was shocked and scared after seeing news of the Grab AV incident near her home.
Some residents expressed wariness toward the technology. Mr Teo, 37, a civil servant, said he does not trust the technology yet and feels the AVs are less predictable. Mr Amri Hakim Mohamed Alias, 41, and his wife said they try to stay away from the vehicles when out with their three children.
Despite these concerns, some residents support the continuation of the trials. Mr Yang Lou, 59, said testing has to continue and is essential to uncover problems before a wider rollout. Mr Heng said he likes having AVs in the neighbourhood and takes pride in Punggol being at the forefront of innovation. He supported a brief, targeted safety pause but said Singapore should not overreact at the first sign of trouble.
The Ministry of Transport (MOT) said AVs are being trialled to augment the public transport network. In Punggol, fixed-route shuttles complement existing services by bringing residents from residential estates to amenities like MRT stations and polyclinics. As of Nov 3, 15 passenger AVs were operating in Punggol.
Key facts
- Grab was directed to pause testing at certain junctions and ComfortDelGro was told to pause U-turns at the Punggol Field junction.
- A Grab AV nearly hit a schoolgirl while making a discretionary left turn.
- A ComfortDelGro AV turned into the path of an approaching vehicle during a U-turn on Nov 5.
- As of Nov 3, 15 passenger AVs were operating in Punggol.
Three perspectives
Neutral
Autonomous vehicle trials in Punggol have faced safety pauses following incidents involving a near-miss with a pedestrian and a vehicle turning into traffic.
Positive
Residents like Mr Yang Lou and Mr Heng support the trials, noting that testing is essential to uncover problems and that Punggol is at the forefront of innovation.
Negative
Parents and residents expressed worry and scepticism regarding the predictability and safety of autonomous vehicles in residential areas.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.