Some specialists charge triple the fees of peers, Grattan Institute finds

Extreme specialist fees are becoming more common, affecting 2.2 million patients in 2025.

Some specialists charge triple the fees of peers, Grattan Institute finds
Photo: The Guardian

Some specialists routinely charge patients much more than their peers, according to a report from the Grattan Institute. The most expensive 5% of psychiatrists charge a median out-of-pocket fee of $669 for an initial consultation, which is 104% more than their peers. High-cost paediatricians charge $362, or 212% more than their peers, while high-cost cardiologists charge $265.11, which is 203% more.

Extreme fees are becoming more common, with 250,000 extra patients paying them each year, affecting 2.2 million patients in 2025. The average specialist fee rose 4% on top of inflation in 2025.

Health economist Peter Breadon, the report's lead author, said the market is failing to self-regulate because there is little competition due to a lack of specialists and long public wait times.

The Grattan Institute recommends that the government force any specialist whose annual fees average more than three times the Medicare schedule fee to repay the government for all rebates claimed that year. Patients would keep their rebate. This would affect roughly 6% of specialists nationwide, including more than 60% of private dermatologists and a quarter of obstetrician-gynaecologists.

Federal health minister Mark Butler said all options are on the table to rein in climbing specialist fees. The government has established a specialist affordability working group to advise on reforms, of which Breadon is a member. Dr Julian Kelly, the Royal College of Physicians president-elect, said the body would support the government in introducing regulation to address extreme charging.

Key facts

  • The most expensive 5% of psychiatrists charge a median out-of-pocket fee of $669 for an initial consultation.
  • Extreme fees affected 2.2 million patients in 2025.
  • Specialists increased patient fees by an average of $37 between 2012 and 2025, while Medicare rebates fell in real terms by $9.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The Grattan Institute report found that some specialists charge up to triple the fees of their peers, which cannot be justified by business running costs or inadequate government rebates.

Positive

Federal health minister Mark Butler said all options are on the table to rein in climbing specialist fees.

Negative

The chief executive of the Consumers Health Forum, Dr Elizabeth Deveny, said Australians are increasingly rationing their own care or skipping follow-ups because gap costs exceed a week of groceries.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Next storyBacteria becoming resistant to last-resort antibiotics, WHO warns

All sections

Edition