Independent reanalysis reproduces M87 black hole ring image
A CSIRO-led team used a new algorithm and machine learning to recover the iconic ring shape, confirming general relativity's description of spacetime.
A CSIRO-led team in Western Australia has independently reprocessed original Event Horizon Telescope data and recovered the same ring-shaped image of the M87 black hole released in 2019. The reconstructed image is nearly identical in size and shape to the original, according to a paper published in Nature on Nov. 12.
The researchers used a new algorithm that groups telescopes in threes to cancel atmospheric and instrumental error, along with machine learning trained on non-black-hole images. This approach differs from the EHT process, which combined telescope data in pairs. The new model had no idea what a black hole looked like when applied to the M87 data, which prevented expectations from biasing the output.
The result answers a 2022 challenge from Kobe University researchers who found no ring under altered assumptions, finding only a clump of radio emission. This independent validation confirms that general relativity accurately describes the warped spacetime around the black hole.
The 2019 image was assembled from April 2017 observations taken by radio telescopes at eight sites, including the South Pole, Chile and Antarctica, acting as a single Earth-sized antenna. Because there are only a small number of telescopes scattered around the world, large gaps in measurements must be filled in by imaging algorithms. Additionally, observations at very short radio wavelengths can be distorted by the atmosphere.
Samuel Lai, a postdoctoral fellow at CSIRO and the study's lead author, said the work is the first truly independent validation of the EHT image. Nithyanandan Thyagarajan, the CSIRO researcher who supervised the work, noted that the sparse geometry of the network left room for interpretation.
Laurent Loinard, director of the Event Horizon Telescope, said it is gratifying to see an independent method recover the ring structure in excellent agreement with the EHT Collaboration's results. The agreement suggests the ring is a stable feature of the source rather than a quirk of a single processing run.
Key facts
- A CSIRO-led team reprocessed Event Horizon Telescope data to reproduce the M87 black hole ring image.
- The study was published in Nature on Nov. 12.
- The new imaging algorithm groups telescopes in threes to cancel errors.
Three perspectives
Neutral
A CSIRO-led team reprocessed original Event Horizon Telescope data and recovered the same ring-shaped image of the M87 black hole released in 2019.
Positive
The independent reanalysis confirms that general relativity accurately describes the warped spacetime around the black hole.
Negative
In 2022, Kobe University researchers reported that applying different assumptions produced no ring at all, only a clump of radio emission.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.