Lawyers for Lindsay Clancy seek dismissal amid juror misconduct allegations
Defense attorneys argue for dismissal of the murder case following allegations that a holdout juror used a cellphone and provided dishonest information during selection.

Lindsay Clancy's lawyers asked a Massachusetts judge on Monday to throw out her murder case, following allegations involving the lone juror whose vote helped produce a mistrial. The hearing in Plymouth Superior Court revisited the breakdown of Clancy's first trial regarding the 2023 deaths of her three young children. Clancy, 36, has not disputed killing her children.
Defense attorney Kevin Reddington told the court that the defense obtained information indicating the holdout juror used a cellphone during the case. Reddington said another juror reported seeing him scrolling on the device and alleged he researched terms connected with evidence presented at trial. The defense argued these allegations raise questions about whether outside information entered the jury's deliberations.
The juror's attorney disputed the characterization, arguing that the account amounted to the juror having a phone in hand at times, not proof of research or contact. She also stated every juror had been allowed to keep a phone. Reddington also questioned information the juror supplied during jury selection and sought to discuss alleged prior criminal or court matters. He told the court he had evidence the man was not honest on his form.
Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague warned that if an investigation into the holdout juror is allowed, the inquiry may not stop with him. Sprague said post-mistrial statements about other jurors raised questions about cellphone use and matters they may have considered. She argued that scrutiny based on post-trial statements could potentially sweep in the entire panel.
Defense attorney Martin Weinberg argued that Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial without sufficiently investigating two notes from the jury foreperson suggesting one juror was not properly applying reasonable-doubt instructions. The prosecution maintained that Clancy understood what she was doing and acted deliberately. The jury ultimately deadlocked in September with an 11-1 split in favor of finding her not criminally responsible.
The court is scheduled to reconvene November 16 before a possible March retrial. Prosecutors said they are headed toward another trial, although the precise charges and timing remain unresolved. Judge Sullivan's pending decisions could determine whether Clancy can be prosecuted again.
Key facts
- Lindsay Clancy's lawyers are seeking to have her murder case dismissed.
- Allegations emerged that a holdout juror used a cellphone to research evidence during the trial.
- The first trial ended in a mistrial in September after an 11-1 split regarding whether Clancy was criminally responsible.
- The court is scheduled to reconvene on November 16.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The court is weighing whether to dismiss the murder case against Lindsay Clancy or proceed with a retrial following allegations of juror misconduct.
Positive
The court is addressing allegations of juror misconduct to ensure the integrity of the legal process.
Negative
The defense alleges that a juror was dishonest during selection and used a cellphone to research the case.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
