Greens hold balance of power over Labor tax bills
The Greens could support two major tax bills by the end of next week if the government commits to reforming the charities sector.
The Greens may pass two major tax bills for the Labor government by the end of next week if the minor party secures a promise to reform the charities sector. The government is also seeking to pass a bill that would carve out start-ups from a new capital gains tax regime.
The Greens are the only viable pathway for the legislation in the Senate because the Coalition is opposed. While the party is comfortable with the principle of both measures, they require specific changes. Their primary concern regarding trusts is an exemption that allows income tax-exempt entities, such as private schools and sporting clubs, to avoid the 30 per cent tax. The Greens want this exemption repealed and a commitment to consider broader reforms for the charitable sector, including the tax treatment of religious institutions.
Regarding the capital gains tax, the Greens have no major issues with the proposed start-up carve-out. The concession would apply to businesses less than 15 years old that are developing or commercialising innovative products, processes, services, or methods.
Independent MP Allegra Spender proposed an alternative where any active business assets would receive a 40 per cent discount. Mr Chalmers wrote to Ms Spender stating that Treasury believes her proposal would be inequitable and would introduce more complexity rather than less. He argued that her model would replace one arbitrary distortion with another and could encourage people to restructure assets for tax reasons.
Ms Spender said her proposal is gaining support in the business community and called for the government to evaluate its advantages. She also suggested a parliamentary inquiry into the matter. The Greens have expressed no particular inclination to support Ms Spender's model, despite earlier comments from Senator McKim suggesting openness to it.
Key facts
- The Greens require a commitment to charity sector reform to support the government's tax bills.
- Treasurer Jim Chalmers intends to introduce a 30 per cent tax on discretionary trusts this Wednesday.
- The proposed capital gains tax carve-out applies to innovative businesses less than 15 years old.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The government is seeking to pass two tax bills through the Senate by the end of next week, with the Greens' support depending on reforms to the charities sector.
Positive
The Greens are broadly supportive of the principle of the new tax measures and the start-up carve-out.
Negative
The Coalition opposes the tax bills, and the Treasurer has rejected an alternative proposal from Allegra Spender, claiming it would be inequitable and complex.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
