Kelly Clarkson and Brooklyn boutique in dispute over $15,000 mechanical bird
A public feud between singer Kelly Clarkson and Art of Play has led to online backlash and claims of threats against the small business.

Singer Kelly Clarkson is involved in a public dispute with Art of Play, a Brooklyn boutique, regarding the purchase of a $15,000 mechanical bird. Clarkson claimed an employee judged her based on her appearance and suggested she look at something comparable instead of the bird.
Art of Play responded on Instagram, stating the business was attacked by 8 million people following the singer's accusations. The store clarified that the mechanical bird, named Molly, is a permanent mascot attached to the wall, but a nearly identical automaton owned by artist Bliss Kolb was available for $15,000.
Clarkson responded on X and Instagram, calling the store a liar and asserting that the conversation about the bird being for sale did happen. She stated she supports small businesses but said they do not get a free pass to treat people poorly.
Adam Rubin, co-owner of Art of Play, said the singer has put his business in danger. He claimed the backlash included people associated with the business being attacked, threatened, and doxed. Crisis PR expert Steve Honig noted that while some may see Clarkson as acting like a prima donna, most may see her as a role model for standing up for herself.
Evan Nierman, CEO of Red Banyan, said Clarkson's established reputation will likely protect her from lasting damage, though continuing the discussion could change how people view her.
Key facts
- Kelly Clarkson disputed a sales experience at Art of Play in Brooklyn involving a $15,000 mechanical bird.
- Art of Play reported receiving hateful messages from 8 million people after the singer's post.
- Co-owner Adam Rubin claimed staff and neighbors have been threatened and doxed.
Three perspectives
Neutral
Kelly Clarkson and the Brooklyn boutique Art of Play have exchanged conflicting accounts regarding a failed $15,000 sale.
Positive
Art of Play expressed hope that they can clear things up with Clarkson and eventually laugh about the misunderstanding.
Negative
The dispute has resulted in the boutique being targeted by widespread online outrage and threats against its staff.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.