Judge rejects bid to dismiss Lindsay Clancy case
A Plymouth judge denied defense attorneys' request to dismiss the case following a mistrial in the deaths of three children.

A Massachusetts judge rejected a bid by attorneys for Lindsay Clancy to have the case against her dismissed. Judge William Sullivan in Plymouth denied the request.
The judge declared a mistrial on 4 September after a jury reported a holdout juror was preventing a unanimous verdict. Defense lawyers argued that a retrial would violate Clancy's constitutional protection against double jeopardy, claiming Sullivan acted prematurely in declaring the mistrial. They argued Sullivan should have questioned or potentially removed the holdout juror instead.
Prosecutors under Plymouth county district attorney Timothy Cruz countered that the judge handled the jury impasse appropriately. They said questioning the holdout could have risked the judge inappropriately interfering with jury deliberations.
The case involves the deaths of Cora, five; Dawson, three; and eight-month-old Callan on 24 January 2023, in the basement of their Duxbury home. No one at the initial trial disputed that Clancy strangled the children with exercise bands. Clancy then cut herself with a knife and jumped from a second-story window in an attempt to end her own life, which left her paralyzed.
Defense lawyers have argued Clancy was in the throes of postpartum psychosis and should be found not guilty by reason of insanity, known in Massachusetts as lack of criminal responsibility. Some jurors later told televised interviews they were prepared to find her not guilty by reason of insanity if not for one holdout juror. A verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity would have resulted in her commitment to a state psychiatric hospital.
Sullivan has scheduled a hearing for 16 November to discuss when to hold a second trial, which he suggested could occur in March. In Massachusetts, a conviction on first-degree murder charges carries a mandatory sentence of life in prison without parole.
Key facts
- Judge William Sullivan rejected the bid by Clancy's attorneys to dismiss the case.
- A mistrial was declared on 4 September after a holdout juror prevented a unanimous verdict.
- A hearing is scheduled for 16 November to discuss a potential second trial in March.
Three perspectives
Neutral
A judge rejected a motion to dismiss the case against Lindsay Clancy and scheduled a hearing to discuss a second trial.
Positive
A hearing has been scheduled for 16 November to determine the timeline for a second trial.
Negative
Defense lawyers argued that a retrial would violate Clancy's constitutional protection against double jeopardy.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.