Minister and Law Society reach agreement on legal aid dispute

The dispute over a new flat fee payment scheme for criminal legal aid cases has been resolved following a High Court ruling.

Minister and Law Society reach agreement on legal aid dispute
Photo: RTÉ

The dispute between criminal legal aid solicitors and the Minister for Justice over a new payment scheme has been resolved. Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan said an agreement had been reached with the Law Society after extensive talks.

The department said the flat fee structure would remain and multiple legal aid certificates would no longer be granted for separate and distinct cases. However, enhanced payments will be made for separate and distinct cases involving two or more charges brought on the same day. Enhanced payments will also be provided for domestic violence cases, cases involving children and cases where the accused goes into custody before trial.

Jim O'Callaghan said the reforms which were the basis of the changes he implemented in July remained. This includes the flat fee model which removed fees based on the number of court appearances and ended multiple certificates for one accused. The minister said this would result in a more efficient and cost-effective criminal justice system.

The Law Society said the agreement addressed its two core concerns regarding the treatment of separate cases coming before the court on the same day and payment for more complicated cases. President of the Society Martin Lawlor said they welcomed the department’s constructive engagement and that the agreement was an important step towards an effective sustainable scheme protecting access to justice for everyone.

The dispute had lasted almost five months. The new regulations provided for a flat fee of €520 per accused person, regardless of the number of charges, the connection between the charges or the number of court appearances. Parts of the scheme were described as unfair and illogical in a High Court ruling last week.

Many solicitors withdrew their services as a protest against the new regulations. This action has disrupted the criminal justice system since July, leading to backlogs and adjournments.

Key facts

  • The Minister for Justice and the Law Society have reached an agreement to resolve a dispute over legal aid payments.
  • The new scheme includes a flat fee of €520 per accused person.
  • Enhanced payments will be made for domestic violence, cases involving children, and cases where the accused goes into custody before trial.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The Minister for Justice and the Law Society have reached an agreement regarding a new flat fee payment scheme for criminal legal aid.

Positive

The Law Society said the agreement addresses core concerns and is an important step towards protecting access to justice.

Negative

The dispute and solicitor protests have disrupted the criminal justice system since July, causing backlogs and adjournments.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition