Court rules Northern Secretary's Drumcree parade ban was lawful
A Belfast High Court judge dismissed a challenge to Chris Bryant's decision to stop the Orange Order procession along the Garvaghy Road.
A Belfast High Court has ruled that Northern Ireland Secretary Chris Bryant made a lawful decision when he banned the Drumcree parade earlier this month.
The decision followed a challenge by the Portadown district of the Orange Order regarding the legality of the decision-making route used to halt the procession. Bryant intervened on 9 October after a 13-day stand-off between Orangemen and residents of the mainly nationalist Garvaghy Road.
The court heard that facilitating the parade would have required a huge policing operation due to a large nationalist counter-protest. PSNI intelligence indicated dissident republicans might have mounted gun attacks on police if officers had cleared a route, and there was a risk weapons might be used.
Mr Justice Scoffield said those who opposed the march should take no particular joy in the outcome, noting the situation was brought about at significant financial cost and in terms of community relations. He added that while the existence of a right does not require its exercise, law protects freedoms of assembly that others may find unwelcome.
Loyalist activist and legal adviser Jamie Bryson insisted the organisation will walk the Garvaghy Road and said they will likely be lodging an appeal. Conversely, Garvaghy Road residents' spokesman Breandán Mac Cionnaith said the position of the community has been fully vindicated.
Taoiseach Micheál Martin said there is a need to strengthen and develop community relationships following the ruling. The PSNI said it welcomes the finding that the Chief Constable’s decision to seek a review and the subsequent decisions of the Secretary of State were lawful.
Key facts
- The Northern Secretary Chris Bryant intervened on 9 October following a 13-day stand-off.
- The Orange Order indicated an appeal is likely.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The Belfast High Court dismissed a judicial review challenge against the decision to ban the Drumcree Orange Order parade.
Positive
The PSNI welcomed the court's finding that the decisions made by the Chief Constable and the Secretary of State were lawful.
Negative
The judge noted the situation was brought about at significant cost to the people of Northern Ireland through the diversion of police resources and damage to community relations.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.