US vaccine recommendations stalled as health secretary fails to appoint new panel

Robert F Kennedy Jr, the US Department of Health and Human Services secretary, has made sweeping changes to vaccination policy, including cutting childhood immunization recommendations by a third.

US vaccine recommendations stalled as health secretary fails to appoint new panel
Photo: The Guardian

Robert F Kennedy Jr, the US Department of Health and Human Services secretary, has made sweeping changes to vaccination policy, including cutting childhood immunization recommendations by a third. He replaced experts on the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) with his own handpicked allies. Although a judge's order halted these changes because they were not done correctly, Kennedy has not nominated any new ACIP members.

For example, a new mRNA flu shot is not covered by insurance because it is not listed as an ACIP vaccine. A retired public health employee in Oklahoma, Kroening, reported being charged a $40 co-pay for the shot because of this lack of recommendation.

If the ACIP does not recommend a new shot by the end of the year, insurers will not be required to cover it until January 2029 at the earliest. Typically, if a vaccine is recommended in December 2026, insurers must cover it by January 2028. However, if the recommendation is delayed until January 2027, the coverage requirement is pushed to January 2029.

Experts suggest the federal government is choosing not to put a new ACIP in place. Dorit Reiss, a vaccines expert at UC Law San Francisco, said Kennedy may be delaying the reconstitution of the committee to allow him to make his own recommendations.

The uncertainty has other effects, as some states do not allow pharmacists to administer vaccines without an ACIP recommendation. Additionally, some decisions made by the committee before it was disbanded, such as a September 2025 recommendation for RSV shots, have been halted.

Key facts

  • Robert F Kennedy Jr has not nominated new members to the ACIP, meaning no new vaccination recommendations are coming.
  • Insurers may not be required to cover new vaccines until January 2029 at the earliest if recommendations are delayed.
  • Kennedy has cut childhood immunization recommendations by one third.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The US Department of Health and Human Services is currently without a functioning Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices following a judge's order and a lack of new nominations.

Positive

The US government has appealed the judge's order that disbanded the vaccines committee.

Negative

The lack of ACIP recommendations is creating financial barriers for patients, such as $40 co-pays for new vaccines.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition