Dialysis should not be default for older kidney patients, study finds

A University of Bristol study suggests managing symptoms at home can offer similar quality and length of life to dialysis for older people with kidney failure.

Research led by the University of Bristol suggests that a structured programme of care focused on managing symptoms in a less medicalised way can provide similar results.

The nine-year study involved nearly 500 patients, most of whom were over 80 and many of whom had other health issues such as cancer or heart disease. Participants were randomly assigned to either prepare for dialysis or prepare for responsive management at home. Over an average follow-up period of 4.5 years, researchers found that neither approach resulted in better outcomes when considering quality of life and length of life together.

Professor Fergus Caskey, a kidney consultant at Bristol NHS Group, said neither treatment was superior to the other regarding overall life length and quality. He noted that while dialysis is a life-saving option for younger people, it is a huge undertaking that can be very exhausting for older patients. Dialysis requires hospital visits three times a week, usually for at least four hours at a time.

Lyn Watts, 77, from Kingswood in South Gloucestershire, was randomly chosen to receive the alternative to dialysis in January 2024. She had previously decided she would only undergo dialysis if her symptoms progressed because she did not want three days a week taken from her life. Since joining the study, her kidney function has remained fairly stable, though she said it has slowed her life down.

Fiona Loud from the charity Kidney Care UK said the study allows patients to weigh the balance of treatment against what they value most at the end of life. The charity noted that 7.2 million people in the UK live with some level of chronic kidney disease. Professor Caskey said patients should be told the pros and cons of both options and supported to choose the care that fits their priorities.

Key facts

  • A University of Bristol study found that managing kidney failure symptoms at home offers similar life quality and length to dialysis for older patients.
  • The nine-year randomised study included almost 500 patients, most of whom were over the age of 80.
  • Dialysis typically requires hospital visits three times a week for at least four hours per session.

Three perspectives

Neutral

A University of Bristol study found that for older patients with kidney failure, managing symptoms at home provides similar quality and length of life compared to dialysis.

Positive

The research could help patients make informed and flexible choices that align with their personal priorities for care.

Negative

Dialysis is a significant undertaking that involves exhausting hospital visits several times a week.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Next storyNHS staff inappropriately accessed patient records over 3,000 times

All sections

Edition