Calls for Malta jury system reform intensify after recent acquittals

The acquittals of Lorin Scicluna and Yorgen Fenech have sparked public anger and scrutiny over jury impartiality and guidance.

Calls for Malta jury system reform intensify after recent acquittals
Photo: Times of Malta

Calls to reform Malta’s jury system continue to intensify following the acquittal of former soldier Lorin Scicluna of the murder of Lassana Cisse. This follows the acquittal of Yorgen Fenech of all charges linked to the murder of Daphne Caruana Galizia two months earlier. Both decisions sparked public anger and renewed scrutiny of the system.

Critics have questioned whether the system can consistently draw impartial juries in a country where many people know one another, or if jurors receive enough guidance to assess complex evidence. Defenders of the system argue that the right to be judged by one’s peers has served Malta well.

Justice Minister Clifton Grima said on Monday night that while the jury system should remain, he would welcome a “mature discussion” on the topic. He noted that scrapping the system would require installing a better alternative.

Other European models include systems where professional judges run trials exclusively, such as in Latvia, Lithuania, Romania and the Netherlands. In Cyprus, serious crimes are tried by a panel of three judges with no lay jurors, while minor crimes are tried by a single judge.

Mixed tribunals, where lay jurors and professional judges work together, are widespread across Europe. In Germany, higher criminal courts use a five-person panel with three professional and two lay judges for serious cases. Italy uses a similar model for some serious crimes, involving six lay judges alongside two professional judges.

Key facts

  • Lorin Scicluna was acquitted of the murder of Lassana Cisse.
  • Yorgen Fenech was cleared of all charges linked to the murder of Daphne Caruana Galizia.
  • Justice Minister Clifton Grima said he would welcome a mature discussion on the jury system.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The acquittal of Lorin Scicluna and Yorgen Fenech has led to renewed debate regarding the necessity and effectiveness of Malta's jury system.

Positive

Justice Minister Clifton Grima stated he would welcome a mature discussion on the jury system.

Negative

The recent acquittals have sparked public anger and questions regarding jury impartiality and the ability of jurors to assess complex evidence.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition