Federal deep-sea mining proposal faces opposition in American Samoa

The federal government's plan to mine 31 million acres of ocean waters is being challenged by local leaders and environmental groups in court.

Federal deep-sea mining proposal faces opposition in American Samoa
Photo: Hawaii News Now

The federal government is moving forward with a proposal for deep-sea mining across approximately 31 million acres of ocean waters surrounding American Samoa. This would be the first commercial-scale ocean mining operation in the world.

Opponents have taken legal action to halt the plan, and a hearing is scheduled in the U.S. District Court in Honolulu at the end of the month. Attorney David Henkin of the environmental nonprofit Earthjustice said the Trump administration is rushing forward with a reckless effort and does not seem to care about environmental laws or the impact on the environment.

Sabrina Suluai-Mahuka of the environmental organization Finafinau said the group opposes deep-sea mining because it does not make sense economically, environmentally, or culturally.

Henkin added that mining creates plumes of toxic chemicals and discharges sediment into the ocean where fish like ahi tuna could be exposed to toxic sediment. American Samoa’s governor and other key leaders have also expressed opposition to the proposal.

State Rep. Elijah Pierick said he sees benefits for batteries and military purposes if the practice is found to not pose severe environmental threats. He said any administration should respect the locals and their understanding of the environment, noting that American Samoa's delegates want to protect their waters, ecosystem, and way of life.

Key facts

  • The federal government proposed deep-sea mining in about 31 million acres of water off American Samoa.
  • Earthjustice has a hearing in U.S. District Court in Honolulu at the end of the month.
  • The proposal would be the first commercial-scale ocean mining operation in the world.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The federal government's proposal for deep-sea mining off American Samoa is moving forward despite opposition from elected officials and residents.

Positive

State Rep. Elijah Pierick noted potential benefits for batteries and military purposes if the practice does not pose severe environmental threats.

Negative

Opponents argue the mining would create toxic chemical plumes and sediment that could expose fish to toxins.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition