Job guarantee idea gains attention as AI experts predict mass unemployment

Influential voices warn that rapid AI advancement could trigger widespread job loss, prompting renewed interest in a public option for employment.

Job guarantee idea gains attention as AI experts predict mass unemployment
Photo: The Guardian

Influential voices are predicting that artificial intelligence may trigger crises of vast magnitude. Bill Gates has stated that AI will advance so rapidly that humans will not be needed for most things within a decade. Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei warned the technology could cause widespread unemployment within one to five years, affecting many white-collar professions in law, tech, and finance.

A job guarantee is attracting growing support as a policy to mitigate potential AI-related job loss. The concept involves creating a public option for employment to protect people from the financial and psychological damage of joblessness. Supporters argue it could mobilize a labor force to tackle societal problems such as infrastructure, climate adaptation, elder care, and childcare.

While often grouped with universal basic income (UBI), a recent global survey found greater support for job guarantees than UBI. Polling of Americans by David Shor also shows greater support for creating well-paid jobs than for direct income support. Algernon Austin of the Center for Economic and Policy Research said a job guarantee is preferable to UBI because work provides experience, skills, and a network.

Economists view the costs and benefits of such programs through different lenses. Max Kasy, a professor of economics at Oxford, said that while wages are a cost, programs can save money by reducing the need for unemployment, disability, or early retirement benefits. He added that workers pay taxes and social insurance contributions, providing additional revenue for the state.

Pavlina Tcherneva, a professor of economics at Bard College, said providing a good job is transformative. She noted that factoring in the costs of health problems from long-term unemployment makes the policy an investment. In September, US Representative Ayanna Pressley reintroduced a congressional resolution calling for a federal job guarantee. Her proposal would create a federally funded but locally administered program paying at least $25 an hour.

Key facts

  • Dario Amodei warned AI could cause widespread unemployment in white-collar sectors within one to five years.
  • A job guarantee could pay participants at least $25 an hour under a proposal by Ayanna Pressley.
  • Polling shows Americans favor well-paid jobs over direct income support like UBI.

Three perspectives

Neutral

A job guarantee is a policy idea being discussed as a response to potential AI-driven economic crises.

Positive

Supporters argue a job guarantee can provide dignity, connection, and skills while addressing urgent societal needs.

Negative

Republican Senator John Kennedy suggested a job guarantee would cost trillions of dollars and is impossible.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Anthropic prepares for $1.4tn IPO as AI market faces uncertainty
Next storyAnthropic prepares for $1.4tn IPO as AI market faces uncertainty

All sections

Edition