Trump and Musk clash over Starshield restrictions in Ukraine

A dispute has erupted between Donald Trump, Elon Musk and Volodymyr Zelenskyy over whether the US government or SpaceX is responsible for limiting Starshield access in Ukraine.

Trump and Musk clash over Starshield restrictions in Ukraine
Photo: The Guardian

A war of words has erupted over who is responsible for restrictions on Starshield access in Ukraine. Ukrainian officials say the restrictions have rendered many drones used to strike behind frontlines inoperable and have hampered air defence systems. Civilian casualties in Ukraine have surged as the question of responsibility remains unanswered.

Donald Trump has denied responsibility for the changes to Starshield, stating last Friday that he did not know if anyone was responsible, but that it was not him or Elon Musk. He said on Thursday that the service had resumed and that Musk had "put it back". However, sources within the Ukrainian defence ministry say they have seen no confirmation that these restrictions have been lifted. They reported that drones experiencing speeds of 161km/h (100mph) were losing connection.

Republican Senator John Cornyn said he did not believe Musk would have acted without at least the acquiescence of the White House.

Elon Musk has blamed the Trump administration, writing on X that the systems are owned and controlled by the US government and that any limits on speed or usage are decided by the US military and the president.

President Volodymyr Zelenskyy initially blamed SpaceX and the United States, stating the move would bring human losses and that people will die. He said at the weekend that SpaceX was ultimately responsible for suddenly limiting the speed at which Starshield worked in Ukraine, though he noted that technically SpaceX did it as a message from the American government. Zelenskyy also noted that there were no similar restrictions on Starshield terminals in European Union countries.

Key facts

  • Ukrainian officials say Starshield restrictions have hampered air defence and rendered drones inoperable.
  • Donald Trump stated that Elon Musk has "put it back" regarding the Starshield service.
  • Ukrainian defence ministry sources say there is currently no confirmation that restrictions have been lifted.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The US government and Elon Musk have traded accusations regarding the cause of Starshield connectivity issues in Ukraine.

Positive

Donald Trump stated on Thursday that the Starshield service had resumed.

Negative

Ukrainian officials report that the restrictions have led to a surge in civilian casualties and hampered military operations.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Trump to hold first trilateral summit with Xi and Putin in China
Next storyTrump to hold first trilateral summit with Xi and Putin in China

All sections

Edition