FCC ruling limits harassment protections for women in Punjab and KP
The Federal Constitutional Court ruled in Usman Shahid v Nadia Sarwar that behaviour at work only counts as harassment under the 2010 law if it has a sexual element.

The Federal Constitutional Court ruled in Usman Shahid v Nadia Sarwar that behaviour at work only counts as harassment under the 2010 law if it has a sexual element. Under this ruling, bias, humiliation, or hostility against a woman because she is a woman is not enough on its own.
In Punjab and KP, the old, sexual-only definition is still the law.
The ruling removes protections that women in these provinces previously accessed through the Supreme Court’s 2023 Nadia Naz review, which read the old law broadly enough to cover gender-based discrimination. As a result, a federal bank employee in Lahore can still complain about gender-based hostility, while a doctor at a Punjab government hospital facing the same treatment now cannot.
Barrister Rida Hosain said the 2022 amendments have not been adopted in Punjab, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa or Balochistan and that the outrage over the FCC judgment is entirely justified. The judgment represents a serious rollback of legal protection afforded to victims, as victims risk being denied legal protection simply because the harassment they experience is not sexual in nature.
The 2022 amendment was passed months after a 2021 Supreme Court judgement called the Act "cosmetic" and "myopic" for its restricted meaning. Parliament acted to provide a legislative fix for that judicial reading, though some critics argue the 2022 amendment made the previous broad reading redundant.
Key facts
- The FCC ruled that harassment under the 2010 law must have a sexual element.
- Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa have not adopted the 2022 amendments covering gender discrimination.
- The 2022 amendments apply only to federal law and in Sindh.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The Federal Constitutional Court ruled that harassment under the 2010 law requires a sexual element, a standard that applies in provinces like Punjab and KP where 2022 amendments were not adopted.
Positive
Women in federal organisations and Sindh remain protected against gender discrimination due to a 2022 amendment.
Negative
The FCC verdict removes protections for women in Punjab and KP, meaning gender-based hostility that is not sexual may no longer be legally protected.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.