UK court rules Chagos right of abode decision must be heard in London

The British Indian Ocean Territories (BIOT) court of appeal has ruled that a previous judge's decision that Chagos islanders now have a right of abode was not valid.

UK court rules Chagos right of abode decision must be heard in London
Photo: AOL

The British Indian Ocean Territories (BIOT) court of appeal has ruled that a previous judge's decision that Chagos islanders now have a right of abode was not valid. The judges said the decision needs to be made by the Court of Appeal in England. This ruling helps the Labour government progress its deal to hand over the islands to Mauritius, but the legal battle now moves to London.

The judges at the court of appeal included Sir Howard Morrisson, Mr Justice Lane, Mrs Justice Nott, Mrs Justice Plimmer and Mr Justice Bird. They stated the BIOT court was the wrong one to decide on the right of abode. The judgement noted that the BIOT constitution is made by the Royal Prerogative and lies outside the definition of British Settlement.

Lawyers for the islanders have asked for their case to be heard by the English Court of Appeal and have also put in an appeal to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. The Privy Council meets in Bermuda in April next year. James Tumbridge, the lawyer acting for the islanders, said, "We fight on."

The row follows Sir Keir Starmer's 2024 agreement to hand the islands to Mauritius and pay £30bn to lease back the airbase on Diego Garcia. The deal has faced delays after US president Donald Trump pulled his support. Defence secretary Wes Streeting recently stated that any deal would need the consent of the US, who share the base.

Key facts

  • The BIOT court of appeal ruled that the decision on the right of abode for Chagos islanders must be made by the English Court of Appeal.
  • The legal battle will continue with cases to be heard in London next year.
  • The UK government's deal involves handing the islands to Mauritius and paying £30bn to lease back the Diego Garcia airbase.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The British Indian Ocean Territories court of appeal ruled that the question of whether Chagos islanders have a right of abode must be decided by the English Court of Appeal.

Positive

The ruling helps the Labour government progress its deal to hand the islands over to Mauritius.

Negative

A group of Chagossians who reoccupied an island in protest over the government deal face an uncertain future.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition