High court orders LHDA and Seinoli Trust to negotiate data release
Judge Molefi Makara gave both parties until 17 November to complete out-of-court negotiations regarding data on communities affected by the Lesotho Highlands Water Project.

The high court in Lesotho has ordered the Lesotho Highlands Development Authority (LHDA) and the Seinoli Trust to attempt an out-of-court agreement. On Tuesday, Judge Molefi Makara gave the two parties until 17 November to complete negotiations on the handover of information.
The Seinoli Trust approached the court to overturn a refusal by the LHDA to share data on communities affected by the Lesotho Highlands Water Project. Seinoli argued the data is needed to determine if families have been adequately compensated under the treaty signed by Lesotho and South Africa.
Reitumetse Nkoti-Mabula, executive director of the Seinoli Legal Centre, said the requested information includes census and socioeconomic survey data, land and asset inventories, maps, and photographs. The data also covers improvements such as houses, livestock, rangelands, fruit trees, medicinal plants, and graves. Seinoli also sought disclosure of valuation amounts, compensation offers, signed agreements, and grievance documents.
LHDA chief executive Tente Tente denied the refusal was unlawful, stating the decision complied with the Data Protection Act of 2011. He said releasing the information would violate data protection laws and that the socioeconomic data requested was not available because the LHDA was still undertaking the survey.
Nkoti-Mabula said the refusal made it impossible to evaluate if the LHDA met its obligations to affected communities. She noted that during consultations in 2021 and 2022, about 100 individuals and households complained that life has become more difficult and they had not received full compensation.
An ombudsman report stated that as of 31 December 2025, arrears in compensation for Phase 1 stood at more than M142-million (R142-million). Following the ruling, Seinoli’s advocate, Relebohile Thuhlo, said the organisation would send a letter to the LHDA listing all required information.
Key facts
- Judge Molefi Makara set a deadline of 17 November for out-of-court negotiations.
- Compensation arrears for Phase 1 stood at more than M142-million as of 31 December 2025.
- The LHDA maintains that releasing the data would violate the Data Protection Act of 2011.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The high court has directed the LHDA and the Seinoli Trust to negotiate the release of project-related data out of court.
Positive
The court has provided a deadline of 17 November for both parties to reach an agreement through negotiations.
Negative
Seinoli argues that the LHDA's refusal to share data prevents an evaluation of whether communities were adequately compensated.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.