Government considers expanding welfare changes to all working ages
Ministers are weighing a 'participation first' approach that could replace disability benefits with work and training support for adults as well as young people.

Cabinet ministers are considering applying a 'participation first' principle to all people of working age, which could involve cutting or removing some disability benefits while spending billions more on support to enter the workplace. This move follows plans to replace key disability benefits for young people with work and training.
The government is preparing to accept recommendations from adviser Alan Milburn next week regarding an overhaul of the benefits system for young people. Milburn's report proposes that under-25s receive training and support instead of the universal credit health element. Under these plans, young people with disabilities would lose their personal independence payment but could apply to a local fund for specific short-term expenses and equipment. Those with the most extreme needs who cannot work will have their entitlements protected.
However, ministers said any system for the over-25s would need to reflect different circumstances, such as families, caring responsibilities, and more complex health needs.
Alan Milburn said his report is about providing billions more in support to help young people into work.
The proposals face political risk, as Keir Starmer faced a rebellion from the Labour parliamentary party last year regarding health and disability benefit changes. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation said the proposals could significantly weaken the safety net for hundreds of thousands of young people, potentially leaving many on universal credit with a basic rate of support of about £80 a week.
There has been consternation within the Department of Health and the Department for Education because the upfront funding for Milburn's support may come from within their budgets. Some estimates have placed the cost of the Milburn proposals at around £6bn.
Key facts
- The government is considering applying 'participation first' principles to all working-age adults.
- Alan Milburn's report for young people proposes replacing the universal credit health element with training and support.
- The Milburn proposals could create 440,000 employment and education opportunities by 2036.
- Some estimates put the cost of the Milburn proposals at approximately £6bn.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The government is considering a 'participation first' model that would increase spending on work support while cutting certain disability benefits for young people and potentially adults.
Positive
Alan Milburn stated his proposals would create 440,000 employment and education opportunities by 2036 and raise the net incomes of young people by more than £2bn.
Negative
The Joseph Rowntree Foundation warned that the proposals could weaken the safety net for hundreds of thousands of young people, leaving some on approximately £80 a week.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.