Legal experts question legality of new measures for third-country nationals
New budgetary measures increasing work permit fees and service charges for third-country nationals could breach EU directives, according to law experts.

New budgetary measures affecting third-country nationals could be challenged in court, as law experts suggest the provisions may breach EU directives. The measures, announced last Monday, increase work permit fees for single permit holders and introduce charges for services that are free for locals and EU nationals, such as childcare and public transport.
Third-country nationals without long-term residence will also be required to pay almost €1,000 each year for driving their own car. Robert Abela defended the measures, stating they would help fund infrastructural works.
Human rights lawyer Neil Falzon, head of the NGO Aditus Foundation, said the measures could violate several European directives, most notably the EU’s Single Permit Directive. Falzon stated that single permit holders are entitled to equal treatment regarding access to goods and services, and that public transport and childcare are services made available to the general public. He argued the measures deny single permit holders equal treatment to nationals.
Falzon added that a legal challenge could be supported by the EU’s human rights charter regarding equality and non-discrimination. There are also questions about whether the measures violate the legitimate expectations of third-country nationals residing in Malta. He noted that case law, particularly in the UK, suggests governments cannot arbitrarily change requirements that make it difficult for people to continue an ongoing relationship.
EU law expert Ivan Sammut, head of the University of Malta’s European law department, said the matter is not clear cut. While European law is clear on obligations toward long-term residents, Sammut described the situation for third-country nationals without long-term residence as a “grey area”. He said a potential legal challenge could not be ruled out, but the outcome would depend on the courts’ interpretation.
Sammut noted that Maltese transport authorities previously faced a legal challenge in 2011 when Arriva introduced a two-tier bus fare system. The European Commission disagreed with the government's argument that the distinction was based on residency rather than nationality, eventually forcing authorities to scrap the system.
Key facts
- New measures increase work permit fees for single permit holders and introduce charges for childcare and public transport for third-country nationals.
- Third-country nationals without long-term residence must pay almost €1,000 annually to drive their own cars.
- Law experts suggest the measures may breach the EU’s Single Permit Directive regarding equal treatment.
Three perspectives
Neutral
Legal experts are divided on whether the new budgetary measures for third-country nationals fall into a legal grey area or breach EU directives.
Positive
Robert Abela stated the measures would help fund infrastructural works.
Negative
Critics argue the measures deny single permit holders equal treatment and could violate EU human rights and equality standards.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.