Prediction markets jump on possibility of Justice Samuel Alito retiring
Bettors have wagered nearly $6 million on when the 76-year-old conservative justice will step down, despite his assurances that he has no plans to do so.

Prediction markets jumped again in October at the possibility of Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito retiring. Bettors on Kalshi and Polymarket have wagered nearly $6 million since February guessing when the 76-year-old conservative justice will step down. Alito told Bloomberg News he has no plans to retire this term, even if Democrats retake the US Senate in the Nov. 3 midterms.
The Supreme Court is considering petitions about whether states or federal regulators should oversee prediction exchanges. Nearly $2 million has been wagered on whether the justices will hear a clash between New Jersey and Kalshi about who gets to regulate prediction markets. A coalition of gaming states, more than 140 Native American tribes, and the NFL have urged the justices in Flaherty v. to leave regulation to the states.
Political questions are increasingly drawing large wagers on these platforms. Bettors on Kalshi have put down more than $200 million guessing the 2028 Democratic presidential nominee and more than $100 million on control of the US House after midterms. On the crypto-based version of Polymarket unavailable in the US, one top holder has bet more than $86,000 on Alito remaining, while another stands to make more than $60,000 if a long-shot bet on the justice retiring by the end of the year pays off.
Lawmakers have expressed concern about gambling on the court and whether the justices and their staff have appropriate safeguards. During congressional testimony in July, Justices Amy Coney Barrett and Elena Kagan said all court employees from the justices down are barred from using court information to gain financially. This prohibition covers prediction markets as well.
Kalshi and Polymarket both said they are equipped to catch insider trading on the court. Kalshi fined and banned former Rep. George Santos in August for allegedly manipulating bets about his attendance at the State of the Union address. Federal prosecutors indicted a Google software engineer this year after Polymarket flagged suspicious activity.
Key facts
- Bettors have wagered nearly $6 million on when Justice Samuel Alito will step down.
- The Supreme Court is considering petitions regarding whether states or federal regulators should oversee prediction markets.
- Justices Amy Coney Barrett and Elena Kagan testified that court employees are barred from using court information for financial gain.
Three perspectives
Neutral
The Supreme Court is reviewing petitions to determine if state or federal regulators should oversee prediction markets.
Positive
Kalshi and Polymarket both said they are equipped to catch insider trading on the court.
Negative
Lawmakers have expressed concern about gambling on the court and whether the justices and their staff have appropriate safeguards.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.