Court of Appeal restores ECCO claim over 2024 PINKNIC event

The Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court's Court of Appeal set aside a decision that had struck out ECCO's claim regarding unlicensed performances at the Roseau Botanical Gardens.

Court of Appeal restores ECCO claim over 2024 PINKNIC event
Photo: Dominica News Online

The Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court’s Court of Appeal set aside a decision that had struck out ECCO’s entire claim on the ground that it lacked standing to bring the proceedings. In an order dated 20 October 2026, the court restored the claim for further proceedings in the High Court.

The claim involves the 2024 Carnival fete “PINKNIC” held at the Botanical Gardens in Roseau, for which no ECCO licence was obtained. The dispute concerns ECCO’s legal standing to enforce public-performance rights it says were infringed. The works identified in the proceedings include “Bacchanal Rampage”, “Cho (Hot Head)”, “Balance Batty”, “Like It Like This/Like It Like That” and “Bottle of Rum”.

The Court of Appeal held that the master could not properly determine the disputed questions of ownership and standing without a trial, further evidence and cross-examination. The court also found that the master had misapplied the earlier Mega-Plex decision. The matter now returns to the High Court for continuation towards a trial if the dispute is not settled.

McCarthy MARIE, ECCO’s agent in Dominica, said the ruling confirms that assignments of public-performance rights provide a legal foundation for bringing infringement proceedings. He said he had taken great pains to collect relevant evidence and supporting documentation, including agreements ECCO relies on to establish ownership of the rights in the works named in the statement of claim. Marie said if the country is serious about developing a music industry, the people who create the music must be able to earn from its use.

The Government of Dominica, represented by the Attorney General, is the second defendant and second respondent. The government owns the Botanical Gardens in Roseau, where the alleged infringing performances took place. The order also permits the Attorney General to pursue the remaining ground of its strike-out application: that the claim as pleaded discloses no reasonable cause of action against the Government. Any hearing on that ground must take place before a different master or judge.

Key facts

  • The Court of Appeal set aside the decision that struck out ECCO's claim regarding the 2024 PINKNIC fete.
  • The claim involves unlicensed performances at the Botanical Gardens in Roseau.
  • The matter returns to the High Court for potential trial if the dispute is not settled.

Three perspectives

Neutral

The Court of Appeal restored ECCO's claim for further proceedings in the High Court regarding unlicensed performances at the Botanical Gardens.

Positive

McCarthy MARIE said the ruling confirms that assignments of public-performance rights provide a legal foundation for bringing infringement proceedings.

Negative

The Attorney General may still pursue the ground that the claim discloses no reasonable cause of action against the Government.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition