High Court rules pay equity law changes breached Bill of Rights
A judge found that the government's amendments to the Equal Pay Act discriminated against women.
A New Zealand High Court judge ruled on Thursday that the centre-right coalition government's changes to pay equity rules violated women's rights. High Court Judge Paul Radich found that amendments to the Equal Pay Act breached the Bill of Rights Act through unjustifiable discrimination against women.
The court determined that a formal declaration was necessary to recognise the rights of women in female-dominated jobs whose pay equity claims were impacted. According to a court filing, such a declaration vindicates their positions and ensures the court recognises the importance of the right and the fact that it was breached.
In May 2025, the government modified the Equal Pay Act by making it harder to pursue claims and tightening eligibility. These changes required evidence that work had been undervalued historically and continued to be so.
Following a general election earlier this month, the centre-right National Party is positioned to maintain power with a very slim majority. However, the party could lose control of certain key government ministries to its right-wing coalition partners.
Key facts
- High Court Judge Paul Radich found the Equal Pay Act amendments breached the Bill of Rights Act.
- The government amended the Equal Pay Act in May 2025 to tighten eligibility criteria.
- The Public Service Association was one of five plaintiffs in the legal case.
Three perspectives
Neutral
A High Court judge ruled that the government's overhaul of pay equity rules breached the Bill of Rights Act.
Positive
The Public Service Association called the court's decision a historic day for women in New Zealand.
Negative
The government's changes to the Equal Pay Act cancelled many existing claims and made it more difficult to pursue future ones.
Your week in news, every Wednesday
The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.