Google rejects government request to remove Russell Brand video

The tech company declined a request from the Prison Service to take down a clip featuring a message from the convicted criminal, which officials say causes distress to victims.

Google rejects government request to remove Russell Brand video
Photo: The Guardian

Google has refused a request from the UK government to remove a video posted by the wife of Russell Brand. The clip, shared on the couple's YouTube channel, features Laura Brand reading a message from her husband in which he claims he is not guilty of the offences for which he was jailed. Brand was sentenced to 10 and a half years in prison following convictions for rape and three counts of sexual assault.

The Prison Service of England and Wales requested the removal of the content because it was offensive to Brand's victims and had reached a substantial audience. Google stated it is investigating the new content but noted that the channel has been unable to monetise on YouTube since September 2023, when it was suspended from the YouTube Partner Program.

Former minister Jess Phillips said the government does not have the power to compel platforms to remove the video. She said that Ofcom codes on women's safety online are voluntary and that regulations are almost certainly not in place for the government to demand the content be taken down. Phillips suggested that a second online safety act might be needed because the current framework does not explicitly address prisoners using social media to communicate with the outside world.

Housing minister Matthew Pennycook described the video as abhorrent and disturbing, particularly for victims of Brand's crimes. He stated that the government remains in close dialogue with Google regarding the matter.

Minister for children and families Josh MacAlister said he hoped Google would make the same decision that Meta made, noting that the parent company of Facebook disabled Brand's social media accounts for breaching standards prohibiting accounts that are harmful to the community. Andy Burnham also called on social media companies to take the interviews down, stating that the focus should be on the victims rather than hearing from a convicted criminal.

Key facts

  • Google declined a request from the Prison Service to remove a video of Russell Brand claiming innocence.
  • Russell Brand was sentenced to 10 and a half years in prison for rape and three counts of sexual assault.
  • Former minister Jess Phillips stated the government lacks the power to force the removal of the video under current regulations.

Three perspectives

Neutral

Google declined a government request to remove a video of Russell Brand claiming innocence, stating that its rules had not been broken.

Positive

The Ministry of Justice and various ministers have called for the removal of the content to protect the interests of victims.

Negative

The video is described by officials as abhorrent and potentially distressing to survivors of sexual abuse.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

Next storyOne missing and 11 injured in attack on ADNOC vessel in Strait of Hormuz

All sections

Edition