Spotify removes 50m AI-generated songs from recommendations

Streaming services and musicians are setting boundaries against AI-generated music as fans vote with streams for analog instrumentation.

Spotify removes 50m AI-generated songs from recommendations
Photo: The Guardian

Spotify announced on Tuesday that it had removed about 50m songs considered AI slop from its recommendations to users over the past year. The company stated that its editors hold the same standard and do not program content identified as slop or spam. While Spotify requires AI persona badges on artist profiles that do not represent a real human being, it does not require individual songs generated by AI to be labeled.

Other streaming services have taken more stringent stances.

Musicians such as A$AP Rocky and Grimes have declared limits on allowable amounts of AI. A$AP Rocky said he prefers to do things practically and that if someone does a totally AI-generated song through prompting, that is their thing. Grimes, who offered a free license of her own voice to AI enthusiasts, has begun promoting her first new album in six years, Psy Opera, which she described as AI-inspired but not AI-generated.

Kelly Clarkson expressed enthusiasm for AI but said she has an issue when AI artists compete on a chart with humans. She suggested there should be a separate chart for them.

Fans are showing a preference for music without obvious modification. Billboard charts show that songs and albums featuring simple voice-and-guitar arrangements or analog instrumentation are dominating. On the Top 200 album charts, most of the Top 10 albums foreground a singer over analog instrumentation, including works by Olivia Rodrigo, Ella Langley, Olivia Dean, Taylor Swift, Noah Kahan, and Morgan Wallen.

Key facts

  • Spotify removed approximately 50m songs considered AI slop from its recommendations over the past year.
  • A$AP Rocky and Grimes stated they accept AI-generated music but will not produce it themselves.
  • Kelly Clarkson suggested that AI artists should compete on a separate chart from humans.

Three perspectives

Neutral

Streaming services, musicians, and fans are confronting the growing presence of AI-generated music and drawing lines in the sand.

Positive

Spotify is removing content identified as slop or spam from its recommendations to maintain editorial standards.

Negative

Fans have little tolerance for AI-generated music and are voting with millions of streams against artifice.

Your week in news, every Wednesday

The biggest stories of the week for your edition, in your inbox every Wednesday morning, your time. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Choose your news coverage

Please choose and confirm your coverage.

All sections

Edition