Inner ear shapes reveal how early monkeys and apes evolved

Researchers studied the inner ear morphology of several fossils to clarify the evolutionary history of catarrhines.

The evolutionary relationships of early catarrhines are contentious. This group includes Old World monkeys and apes.

Scientists analyzed the semicircular canal and vestibule morphology of Saadanius, Pliobates, Victoriapithecus, and Ekembo. They used diffeomorphic deformation-based geometric morphometrics on a broad anthropoid sample to quantify shape variation and infer ancestral morphotypes.

The semicircular canal and vestibule are parts of the inner ear. Morphotypes are ancestral shapes.

Saadanius retains a primitive, platyrrhine-like inner ear. It lacks all crown catarrhine synapomorphies. The tubular ectotympanic in Saadanius must have evolved independently from crown catarrhines, representing homoplasy.

Pliobates and Epipliopithecus share some derived traits with crown catarrhines. Victoriapithecus displays a morphology indistinguishable from extant Old World monkeys. Ekembo exhibits unexpected derived, ape-like features.

These findings support that pliopithecoids are stem catarrhines more derived than Saadanius. The systematic position of Saadanius remains unresolved.

Key facts

  • Saadanius has a primitive, platyrrhine-like inner ear.
  • Pliopithecoids are stem catarrhines more derived than Saadanius.
  • The tubular ectotympanic in Saadanius represents homoplasy.

All sections

Edition