Human belief uses ranks of disbelief to show uncertainty

Testing Wolfgang Spohn's ranking theory shows that people use ranks to distinguish belief, disbelief, and suspension of judgment.

Human belief has a bipolar structure that respects negation. People use ranks of disbelief to express their uncertainty.

Researchers tested Wolfgang Spohn's ranking theory across six experiments. Participants assigned ranks of disbelief to propositions about personal experience and chance devices. They also used ranks for sequential learning and an Ellsberg urn.

Ranking theory is a normative account where belief is graded by ordinal ranks of disbelief. These ranks combine by minimization rather than addition. A two-sided rank function distinguishes belief, disbelief, and suspension of judgment.

Participants respected the Law of Negation in every task except a lottery. They did not disbelieve both a proposition and its complement. However, disjunctions did not follow the Law of Disjunction.

Instead of taking the minimum rank of the disjuncts, participants averaged them. In a learning task, ranks aligned more closely with objective probabilities than subjective probabilities did. In an Ellsberg urn scenario, ranks markedly reduced paradoxical behavior seen with betting.

Key facts

  • Human belief follows a bipolar, negation-respecting structure.
  • Participants averaged ranks for disjunctions instead of using minimization.
  • Ranks aligned more closely with objective probabilities than subjective probabilities in learning tasks.

All sections

Edition